Computers & Electronics

Best Value CPU, Mobo, RAM, VPU?

  • Last Updated:
  • Sep 26th, 2009 11:18 pm
Tags:
None
Member
May 10, 2006
433 posts
3 upvotes

Best Value CPU, Mobo, RAM, VPU?

It's time to upgrade the core components of my system--CPU, motherboard, RAM, and video card (and power supply, if necessary). There's usually a sweet spot when it comes to price for these (especially CPU and video card). A decent investment will get you the best in the mid-range, before dollar per performance point begins to rise and you get into the really high-end stuff. That's what I'm looking for. I've been out of computers for a little too long to know what the current favourites are.

I'd like my new build to be able to do a bit of everything, potentially. Will definitely be doing gaming, though I don't need cutting edge stuff. Budget is variable, though I'd like to come up with the least I could spend for a viable system as well as something a little more luxurious. Value is definitely an issue for me.

As well, I'm interested in upgrades that do and don't include upgrading the video card, depending on your recommendations. If my 8800GS still has life in it, great. If not, I'd be happy to pick up a worthwhile mid-range successor. That would make it easier to stick the stuff I'm upgrading into an old case to act as a back-up, anyway. (I.e., I don't want to spend cash on a cheap PCI-X VPU to get my back-up rig running when I could invest that money in a better card for my main rig.)

Here's what I currently have:

- Athlon 64 3200+
- ECS GF6100-M754
- 1GB DDR-RAM
- 8800 GS 384MB

- Thermaltake 420w (I presume this will likely need to be upgraded?)

Components I don't feel the need to upgrade:

- Audigy 2 ZS
- 500GB HD
- Viewsonic VX2025wm 20.1"
- XP Pro (Probably want to upgrade to Vista/7 eventually--perhaps immediately, if I need 64-bit OS support?)


Your recommendations are appreciated! Thank you.
18 replies
Deal Addict
User avatar
Jun 27, 2004
4182 posts
5 upvotes
Markham
Good start I think ...

$ 50 - Antec Two Hundred Mid-Tower
$116 - Corsair 750W TX
$215 - Core i5 750 (s1156)
$167 - MSI P55GD65
$136 - Corsair XMS3 Dominator 4GB DDR3 2X2GB DDR3-1600 (CMD4GX3M2A1600C8)
$165 - BFG GeForce GTX 260 OC MAXCORE (AMIR $30)
$ 27 - Samsung 22X DVDRW
$ 17 - 2 x GELID Solutions GELID Silent 12 (1000rpm)
$135 - Windows Vista Home Premium 64BIT OEM with Windows 7 Upgrade Offer (66I03525)
------
$1028

- For a 21" LCD you won't need much gfx power for todays games. A used 4890 is also a good alternative.
- i5 750 defiantly best band for the buck right now
- 4GB of ram, so you'll want 64bit OS. Either stick with XP until Oct 22nd or buy Vista and use the upgrade coupon.
- I would very much recommend a HD upgrade, you might not need the space, but the speed of the new 1TB HD's is alot better than your old 500GB.
- 750W - good quality, and you won't have to upgrade it again hopefully.
- There are not good cheap aftermarket heatsinks yet, so you'll probably want to just use stock for now and wait it out a couple months.

Price via pricecanada.com
Deal Fanatic
User avatar
Nov 7, 2006
7523 posts
460 upvotes
Toronto
SB,
Half decent rig but it doesn't spell VALUE (nor BEST for that matter) :cheesygri
Member
May 10, 2006
433 posts
3 upvotes
A grand is a little more than I want to spend, but then I don't need a tower nor the optical drive. I've always had a mixed opinion of MSI, but haven't had a chance to look up that actual board yet. I guess you have to look at them on a case-by-case basis anyway considering that I've heard bad things about even some ASUS models these days.

Would definitely like to know what options exist in the $600-$800 bracket, though. If you tell me this is the sweet spot for performance right now, I could be convinced to fork over the dough. But if I get a minimum decrease yet am able to shave off a few hundred dollars, all the better.

Thanks so far!
Deal Addict
User avatar
Feb 5, 2004
2419 posts
295 upvotes
OCZ StealthXStream OCZ500SXS 500W ATX12V 24PIN Active PFC ATX Power Supply 120MM Fan Black

* Usually Ships in 1 to 2 Business days.

Yes $57.89 $57.89


Gigabyte Radeon Hd 4850 625MHZ 512MB 1.92GHZ DDR3 PCI-E Crossfirex DU-DVI-I Hdcp Hdtv Out Video Card

* Limit 1 per customer.
* Usually Ships in 1 to 2 Business days.
* $20.00 CAD Mail in Rebate for this item - click here

Yes $109.99 $109.99


OCZ Gold XTC PC2-6400 4GB 2X2GB DDR2-800 CL5-5-5-18 DDR2 240PIN Dual Channel Memory Kit

* Usually Ships in 1 to 2 Business days.

Yes $60.35 $60.35


Gigabyte MA790X-UD4P ATX AM3 AMD790X DDR2 CrossFireX 2PCI-E 2PCI SATA2 Sound GBLAN Motherboard

* Usually Ships in 1 to 2 Business days.

Yes $125.14 $125.14


AMD Phenom II X2 550 Black Edition Dual Core Processor Socket AM3 3.1GHZ 7MB Cache 80W Retail Box

* Usually Ships in 1 to 2 Business days.

Yes $119.26 $119.26

How much is shipping & handling?

Province

Shipping Method

Estimated Shipping & Handling:

Sub Total: $472.63
Deal Addict
User avatar
Jun 27, 2004
4182 posts
5 upvotes
Markham
$116 - Corsair 750W TX
$215 - Core i5 750 (s1156)
$167 - MSI P55GD65
$136 - Corsair XMS3 Dominator 4GB DDR3 2X2GB DDR3-1600 (CMD4GX3M2A1600C8)
$144 - Powercolor Radeon HD 4870 770MHZ (AMIR $20)
------
$778

Cut extra that weren't needed. IMO you can't do much better for the money. Also leaves you with a great upgrade path for later.
Deal Addict
User avatar
Feb 5, 2004
2419 posts
295 upvotes
Silver Bullet wrote: $116 - Corsair 750W TX
$215 - Core i5 750 (s1156)
$167 - MSI P55GD65
$136 - Corsair XMS3 Dominator 4GB DDR3 2X2GB DDR3-1600 (CMD4GX3M2A1600C8)
$144 - Powercolor Radeon HD 4870 770MHZ (AMIR $20)
------
$778

Cut extra that weren't needed. IMO you can't do much better for the money. Also leaves you with a great upgrade path for later.
You have no case and no dvd drive.
Deal Addict
User avatar
Jun 27, 2004
4182 posts
5 upvotes
Markham
nite4evr wrote: You have no case and no dvd drive.
Jonathan Bones wrote: A grand is a little more than I want to spend, but then I don't need a tower nor the optical drive. I've always had a mixed opinion of MSI, but haven't had a chance to look up that actual board yet. I guess you have to look at them on a case-by-case basis anyway considering that I've heard bad things about even some ASUS models these days.


....
Member
May 10, 2006
433 posts
3 upvotes
You guys are all being incredibly helpful--thank you very much! This has given me a lot to consider. It would seem that going AMD still gets you good performance at a good price, while choosing Intel gets you the best performance at a slight premium and better upgrade possibilities. Much like when I was last into computers, when AM2 was only about to come on the scene. :razz:

Anyway, I'm thinking I might drop the GPU from my upgrade temporarily, as my wife's new laptop has gone over budget. The 8800GS should hold me for a bit, right? I definitely do want to upgrade down the road (as my back-up box needs a GPU to run, anyway), and hopefully by the time it's more financially feasible I'll score a great deal on the old gen stuff or be able to afford one of the newer cards.

A couple of questions plaguing me:

1) I've always had a tough time figuring out how powerful of a PSU is actually required. Back in the day, I'd calculate that what I had really wasn't enough, yet it would work fine. And the last time I upgraded, machines actually seemed less efficient than they are today. I presume newer GPUs are still beasts, though.

Silver Bullet is pushing for a monster 750W PSU, while nite4evr suggests that an up-to-date 500W is sufficient (and is half the price). Is this because the newer Intel chips are hogs? Or does SB just think it's worth the cost to have something that should exceed my needs until an entirely new generation of hardware? I can never see myself investing in dual GPUs, or anything. Just doesn't seem worth the money for someone like me who games fairly seriously, yet isn't hardcore.

2) Will definitely research this to death, but can you in a few words tell me what the benefits of the Core i5 750 are? Is it light years beyond the Phenom II X2 550? Again, we're talking about doubling the price of the CPU. If the Intels are so awesome, I'll certainly consider it. But if I can upgrade to something even better than the Intel in 2-3 years for another $100, there doesn't seem to be much point when I'm on a budget.

Thanks guys!
Deal Fanatic
User avatar
Feb 25, 2004
5655 posts
149 upvotes
New Westminster
Jonathan Bones wrote: A couple of questions plaguing me:

1) I've always had a tough time figuring out how powerful of a PSU is actually required.
Silver Bullets video card recommendation is here:
http://www.newegg.ca/Product/Product.as ... 0GTX%20260

From their specs:
525W PCI Express-compliant system power supply with a combined 12V current rating of 38A or more*

*Minimum system power requirement based on a PC configured with an Intel Core 2 Extreme QX9650 processor
So 750watts gives you headroom for expansion in the future
2) Will definitely research this to death, but can you in a few words tell me what the benefits of the Core i5 750 are? Is it light years beyond the Phenom II X2 550?
From http://www.anandtech.com/bench/default. ... 7.48.49.50

Pure CPU is at least double the speed. SysMark overall performance appears to be at least 20% faster.
Deal Addict
User avatar
Feb 5, 2004
2419 posts
295 upvotes
Doesn't have to be the Phenom II, the new Athlon II X4 620 is the new quad core for approx same price as the Phenom II I mentioned.

It runs pretty close to Intel's Q8200 but with a much more attractive price point(approx $100).

Don't use the calculator as it'll tell you to have more juice because it's not accurate.

None of your hardware will run exactly 100% full throttle 24/7.

I'm sure a 250W can handle it but you'll be putting too much stress on it.

I tested Antec EarthWatt 500W/Corsair VS550 and OCZ StealthXStream 500W with the setting below.

i7 920 OCd @ 4.0GHz
Gigabyte GA-X58-DS4
6GB DDR3 Ram
1 X Western Digital Black 500GB
1 X Samsung Spinpoint F1 500GB
2 X Western Digital Green 1GB
2 X 4850 1GB OCd
2 X LG DVD-RW Driver
Deal Addict
User avatar
Feb 5, 2004
2419 posts
295 upvotes
CheapScotsman wrote: Silver Bullets video card recommendation is here:
http://www.newegg.ca/Product/Product.as ... 0GTX%20260

From their specs:So 750watts gives you headroom for expansion in the future

From http://www.anandtech.com/bench/default. ... 7.48.49.50

Pure CPU is at least double the speed. SysMark overall performance appears to be at least 20% faster.
That will not likely happen. Reason? Computer become more and more efficient, same goes for gpu and all the other parts. (smaller, less power, higher performance)
And by the time it does happen, he'll be upgrading again.

The power requirement 10yrs ago comparing to now isn't that much of a difference. People THINK they'll need more, but truth is the "headroom" is just a waste of money.

As for the i5, it might be 20% faster but in terms of price and performance ratio (best bang for the buck). AMD is a better price and performance considering it's like 40% cheaper.

I also have a Q6600 @ 3.6GHz and comparing to an i7 920 @ 4.0GHz, I can't see a single difference with bare eyes. Spending money on something with such minimal difference is not worth it, i've walked through that path and I rather save money for a car, house, food, etc....
Deal Fanatic
User avatar
Feb 25, 2004
5655 posts
149 upvotes
New Westminster
nite4evr wrote: Might be 20% faster, but price and performance ratio (best bang for the buck). AMD is a better price and performance considering it's like 40% cheaper.
Just looking at the CPUs ... The X2 550 is $116 while the i5 is $227 so about 1/2 the price but at about 1/2 of the raw CPU performance.

Lets look at the total cost ... an i5 motherboard/CPU combo might be $175 more than a X2 550 + motherboard ... so on a $900 total build ... about 20 percent total price difference for about 20 total performance difference.

The numbers are rough and are used only to delineate the price / performance brackets.

Given that things appear to be somewhat linear, and given that the OP was talking about a "sweet spot" on the price/perf cur ... I am not sure that the i5 is over that sweet spot

However, he also did say he was looking for a mid range system and the i5 is probably more than that.
Deal Addict
User avatar
Feb 5, 2004
2419 posts
295 upvotes
CheapScotsman wrote: Just looking at the CPUS ... The X2 550 is $116 while the i% is $227 so almost 1/2 the price but 1/2 of the raw CPU performance.

Now lets look at the total cost ... given than an i5 motherboard/CPU combo might be $175 price difference (vs a X2 550 + motherboard) then on $900 total build ... about 20 percent total price difference for about 20 total performance difference.

The numbers are rough and are used only to delineate the price brackets.
CPU is over $110 more
Motherboard is like $80 more
RAM price being 2 times or more

With this money you can have a new computer that's comparing with the i5 AND have a PS3 on the side.
or go somewhere and have a good time with your wife.

In REALITY you wont notice the difference. Period!
Deal Fanatic
User avatar
Jun 11, 2001
9475 posts
1610 upvotes
Agreed, also if you're moving over to Vista... do it in one shot, plus you get to use 4+ GB on a 64bit OS.

Vostro 220 w/Q8200 or something like that, nice legit vista64
Replace the PSU w/ a 80+ eff. one at 500w
Get a minimum 4850 gfx or reuse the 8800 if u don't game much.

should be well under budget and no hassle of tinkering involved. i'm using a vostro 220 at the moment with only a dualcore 3ghz and i find it plays most games w/o issues and quiet to boot. internal sound on it sucks but you have that covered. -sg
...zzz...zzz...zzz...

www.heatware.com
Deal Addict
User avatar
Jun 27, 2004
4182 posts
5 upvotes
Markham
$ 80 - Antec EarthWatts 650W (jonnyguru review)
$121 - Gigabyte GA-MA790X-UD4P
$117 - AMD Athlon II X4 620 2.6GHz
$ 28 - OCZ Vendetta 2 (AMIR $18)
$ 56 - OCZ 4GB (2 x 2GB) 240-Pin DDR2 SDRAM DDR2 1066 (OCZ2G10664GK)
$148 - Powercolor Radeon HD 4870 770MHZ (AX4870512MD5)
------
$550

This should be a good balance ... you get everything you need .. good psu, quad core, 4GB of ram and a good graphics card .. not to mention a good heatsink .. all for under $600.

You might consider a new WD 1TB Black hard drive at this price to speed things up even more. IMO the HD is the component you'll notice the most when you upgrade to something that's faster and you use it all the time, gaming or not.

prices via pricecanada.com

Top

Thread Information

There is currently 1 user viewing this thread. (0 members and 1 guest)