Bestbuy sold me a new DVD but it was actually used
They sent me a resealed copy. I know because I had ordered the same DVD in the past from them so I noticed the packaging differences right away.
The plastic on the DVD case is "wavy" from their in house resealing machine (happens on their used games).
Plus I have pictures of the copy they sent me in the past!
It's not a big deal because it was only $5 but I expected behavior better than a typical EBgames would try to pull...
The one they sent me:
The same DVD purchased New from them in the past: