Called up Rogers Relations today, which deal should I get?

[simms]

Hey guys,

I need your advice. I called up Relations today and I got the following offer:

$25/month -- 3 years
unlimited incoming calls anytime
100 daytime outbound calls (until 9)
1000 nighttime outbound calls
call display
1st year free service
choice of nokia 3220, e316 or v220.

- OR -

$23/month (corp plan) -- 2 years
unlimited nights starting at 6pm and weekends
200 daytime
enhanced VM
call display
18c/min long distance coast2coast
free 3way/call waiting during unlimited periods
possible discounted phone (not free though)

which one should I get?
If I get the 25/month, which phone should I get? Probably would want to sell it off to get a T637.

For #1, I don't have to pay the bills for a whole YEAR.

I use 700-1000 minutes a month and rarely go over my 200 daytime. I use maybe about 150 daytime a month.

[champ91]

post this in the roger hot deals forum. Don't need to make another thread here:

and i'd prefer the first one.

[Singh_21]

1st one without a doubt if the first year is completely free...no system access fee,911 etc.....

[Singh_21]

actually I have a better plan right now so wont any but you should go with 1 if those are the only 2 choices you got.

[HowEver]

For these plans you get either unlimited calling for the first year *or* free monthly service fee. Not both. If you got both, woohoo.

Second year, switch to a lower cost plan or look for another deal.

[simms]

For these plans you get either unlimited calling for the first year *or* free monthly service fee. Not both. If you got both, woohoo.

Second year, switch to a lower cost plan or look for another deal.

I didn't say I get unlimited calling. I get unlimited INCOMING calls.

[HughG]

watch out when they say free they dont mean unlimited.
fallen so many times for that .

[simms]

watch out when they say free they dont mean unlimited.
fallen so many times for that .

Right. I am probably going to do this:

I would go with option #1, if it's either free MSF or FOS for one year AND if, and only if, I can switch back to option #2 after one year.

If switching after one yes is a no go, then I will stick with option #2 but ask for a free phone for a 3 year term.

Makes sense?