I don't know much about Rogers plans, 'cause I'm on Telus. But since your friend is a university student, she's a member of Canadian Federation of Students. On a new 2-3 year contract she can get in on the Employee Purchase Plan, which has 200+50 bonus minutes, unlimited evenings from 6pm, caller ID, voicemail, conference calling and call waiting. I just got in on that plan, but depending on your luck with the reps you may have to go personally to the store a couple of times.
There's no competition for me, really. A landline costs like $30 with tax, this plan costs like $32, and a landline comes without voicemail, and you can't use it on the road. If she goes home or goes out fairly often, it's worth the little extra price to have a phone handy in case of emergencies, like your car breaking down in the middle of the road or getting into an accident or something.
Not to mention that if you get an mp3 phone, you can ditch that mp3 player for short trips
