This went on $1.99/100g locally so I bit...very nice, creamy, succulent, smoky, rich. DEFINITELY buying again.
I also tried the PC 2yr smoked cheddar and is was dry and crumbly with a few of those funny crystals that form in old parm and the like. Good; my roommate reacted to it like it was crack but I preferred the Redwood. I am going to (apparently) have to buy it again though.