as for the debate for Montana... yes he is 4-0 in the finals... and yes, he didnt get there anywhere near as many times as Brady as im sure he lost a lot of playoff games as well.. but look at the wins by SF/Montana
1st - 5 point win after CIN got a TD with 10 sec left...so so up 12 with 15 sec left...SF favoured 1.5pts
2nd - 22 point win... SF favoured by 3.5
3rd - 4 pt win at end of game...SF favoured by 7
4th - 45 point win...SF favoured by 12
2 dominating wins... another that was basically a for sure win unless a crazy thing happened.. and one clutch win....Brady with 2 last second FG wins... another with a late game FG to take 10 pt lead (similar to one of SF wins) and 2 late wins by bonehead opposing coaches..
i dunno... just seems to me that Montana was more dominant when it came to playing in the superbowl than Brady more having to try and comeback every time instead of just dominating the game...
I am a massive Peyton Manning fan since the day he was draft... basically your top 5 right now IMO in no particular order is Brady, Manning, Montana, Farve and Marino... with Brees about to overtake Marino and maybe Farve..