Should rapists be castrated?

[d_jedi]

Wondering what opinions are on this. If someone is a rapist, should we make it so they can never do it again?

[guest10586]

[bionicbadger]

Its easier to kill them. There wasn't an option in the poll for that though.

[Montague]

Problem is what if the person turns out to be innocent?

[UrbanPoet]

we dont even have the death penalty...
we dont even have life sentences!!!

[danfromwaterloo]

If rapists should be castrated then theives should have their hands cut off, and liars should have their tongues cut out.

If you want to resort to cruel and unusual punishment, then you might as well go all the way.

[pandaharo]

If rapists should be castrated then theives should have their hands cut off, and liars should have their tongues cut out.

If you want to resort to cruel and unusual punishment, then you might as well go all the way.

Exactly what we need in Canada

[bionicbadger]

If rapists should be castrated then theives should have their hands cut off, and liars should have their tongues cut out.

If you want to resort to cruel and unusual punishment, then you might as well go all the way.

I'm all for it.
It might be argued that its cruel, but it isn't unusual punishment.

DNA testing is pretty convincing for rape cases where the suspect and victim don't know each other.

[Bortman]

Stealing and lieing doesn't take away the will of a person like rape does, so your cruel and unusual punishment thing has no place here.

[15-20_God]

Stealing and lieing doesn't take away the will of a person like rape does, so your cruel and unusual punishment thing has no place here.

tell that to the seniors that had their life savings wiped out by smooth talking telemarketers.

[15-20_God]

DNA testing is pretty convincing for rape cases where the suspect and victim don't know each other.

yes, thats a great idea for one night stands. pick up a chick at a bar, she goes home with you, you stick it in her twat, and you get castrated because she regrets sleeping with you and was too drunk to remember she grabbed your nuts first.

[d_jedi]

yes, thats a great idea for one night stands. pick up a chick at a bar, she goes home with you, you stick it in her twat, and you get castrated because she regrets sleeping with you and was too drunk to remember she grabbed your nuts first.

that isn't rape..

[15-20_God]

that isn't rape..

not if its consensual.

[GreenWeenie]

Wondering what opinions are on this. If someone is a rapist, should we make it so they can never do it again?

Chemically or physically castrated?

[d_jedi]

Chemically or physically castrated?

People can be castrated chemically now?
(No, I don't want the gory details..)