Star Wars vs Star Trek

[McLaren]

Who would win in a fight?

Imperial Star Destroyer


vs

USS Enterprise

[shabby]

Planet Express.

[felix]

Star Trek Star Trek Star Trek Star Trek Star Trek Star Trek

[cmge]

ok.. lets not get started on this one....

[porphyra]

LOL...I have seen this question many a times on many a forum. And somehow it always swings in the favour of the more-fanboy dominated series.

However, I personally believe that the USS Enterprise would kick some serious star destroyer butt. Superior shields, photon torpedoes and the ability to fight at FTL speeds (a big plus over the Star wars universe). Also they seem more manouverable.

And this is just the Enterprise D.

Bring the Enterprise-E, USS Voyager from "Endgame" or the USS Prometheus and we are talking a totally different ballgame.

[luthair]

Trek 'seems' to have more advanced technology. However, aren't star destroyers a lot bigger? There also seems to be a ton of them, not to mention they have fighter craft.

Anyway its a pointless discussion, Wormhole Weapons from Farscape > *

[jordan23]

star trek!

[Cruel_Angel]

is the pwnage~

[Spare-Flair]

You know those balls on the top of the Star Destroyer bridge? Those are a SD's shield emitters. Remember in RoTJ where they just blow them up and then smash a fighter into the bridge the whole thing goes out of control?

Enterprise could easily destroy them while the Enterprise has no outwardly vulnerable shield components.

Star Destroyers are much bigger but despite the size, ST ships with shields (especially Borg and their adaptive shielding) would win. Heck, the damn 17.5 kilometer long Super Star Destroyer is destroyed when a 5 meter long A-Wing crashes into the bridge.

[me!]

oh yeah, give me a cube any day. (so long as it's on my side)

[Talamasca]

That Executor Class ship is just ridiculous. The amount of resources needed to build and maintain a 17km long ship strains the limits of credibility.

I'm not sure what the most powerful Star Trek ship is. Borg Tactical Cube? Jem'Hadar Super Battleship? Species 8472 ship?

[ragin_pyro]

Dude..a Tactical Fusion Cube!..8 tactical cubes..whip the **** outta those..but definatly the Voyager in Endgame would take them all out, that was pwnage.. It was 1 of my favs, jus cause of the action an all the special effects..

[Spare-Flair]

That Executor Class ship is just ridiculous. The amount of resources needed to build and maintain a 17km long ship strains the limits of credibility.

I'm not sure what the most powerful Star Trek ship is. Borg Tactical Cube? Jem'Hadar Super Battleship? Species 8472 ship?

What's even more ridiculous is taking out the exposed bridge will cause the whole thing to suddenly nosedive into the nearest Death Star. What? They don't have any gryoscopes in Star Wars?

The most powerful Star Trek ship is Q in a rubber dingy.

[me!]

That Executor Class ship is just ridiculous. The amount of resources needed to build and maintain a 17km long ship strains the limits of credibility.

I'm not sure what the most powerful Star Trek ship is. Borg Tactical Cube? Jem'Hadar Super Battleship? Species 8472 ship?

haha. Yeah, that executor class is hokey. I think the Enterprise from the future, or the armour plated Voyager from the future with the future Captain Janeway is pretty powerful. But I'd still go with a Cube. Those are awesome.

Don't follow DS9 That whole storey line was just too lame for me.

[Spare-Flair]

haha. Yeah, that executor class is hokey. I think the Enterprise from the future, or the armour plated Voyager from the future with the future Captain Janeway is pretty powerful. But I'd still go with a Cube. Those are awesome.

Don't follow DS9 That whole storey line was just too lame for me.

I don't understand why people always say that and it's usually only people who haven't really watched the show or seen the dominion war. Is 4 seasons of awesome Galactic-spanning war, drama, and a really dark show lame? It's probably the best of all the Trek after TOS.