Personal Finance

Asia top 10 Expat package breakdown

  • Last Updated:
  • May 27th, 2019 8:39 pm
[OP]
Deal Addict
User avatar
Dec 13, 2016
3114 posts
2500 upvotes

Asia top 10 Expat package breakdown

Image
23 replies
Deal Addict
Apr 2, 2010
1691 posts
919 upvotes
GTA
Interesting information...
On another note, I'll surprised middle eastern countries such as United Arab Emirates or Kuwait did not make it.
Deal Addict
Nov 13, 2013
1795 posts
747 upvotes
Ottawa
This is from the employer perspective I guess. As an employee who cares how much tax my employer is paying on my behalf I just care what I actually receive. In other words I am not better off in Japan than Singapore or Hong Kong.
[OP]
Deal Addict
User avatar
Dec 13, 2016
3114 posts
2500 upvotes
Full article from a Thai paper.


http://www.nationmultimedia.com/detail/ ... s/30369903

What is spurring that low cost countries like Thailand are almost on par with Japan, HK and Singapore.

No wonder everything is getting so expensive in Thailand.

martydxb wrote: Interesting information...
On another note, I'll surprised middle eastern countries such as United Arab Emirates or Kuwait did not make it.
Asia focused.
Deal Addict
Oct 18, 2014
1916 posts
808 upvotes
HK
BiegeToyota wrote: No wonder everything is getting so expensive in Thailand.
Still relatively cheaper than western world, if you are able to command the same salary.

That being said, I'm not a big fan of the long working hours in Bangkok (or Asia is general).
Deal Addict
Jan 29, 2017
1747 posts
1237 upvotes
martydxb wrote: Interesting information...
On another note, I'll surprised middle eastern countries such as United Arab Emirates or Kuwait did not make it.
We don't know the methodology behind this data. Expats from Africa, India or Pakistan in UEA and cie earn peanuts so they would drive the avg down. Also these countries provide income tax free compensation (for most) so the overall compensation doesn't have to be as high.

On this, I would have expected Singapore and HK to be higher.
Member
Feb 13, 2017
316 posts
275 upvotes
toronto, ontario
peli33 wrote: We don't know the methodology behind this data. Expats from Africa, India or Pakistan in UEA and cie earn peanuts so they would drive the avg down. Also these countries provide income tax free compensation (for most) so the overall compensation doesn't have to be as high.
+1

On its surface, much of this "data" is bogus.

What is the definition of "middle management"?
What are considered to be "benefits"? This shows all benefits as taxable when, in reality, many benefits (company subsidized housing and even flight allowances) are non-taxable.
Is the "salary" portion assumed to be after-tax cash-in-hand? Does this mean no middle management expat earns more than $100,000 after-tax? Why would a foreign-trained middle manager work at any of these locations since they could earn an equivalent (or better) salary in their home country?

I have first-hand experience with Japan, Hong Kong, and the Philippines. The "benefits" numbers are grossly inflated and the salary portion is grossly undervalued.
Sr. Member
Aug 7, 2014
563 posts
232 upvotes
1) These foreign expats are generally highly foreign educated, with work experience and/or connections
2) They are generally bi or tri linguals, with fluent in local languages
3) They work long hours

Many middle managers in north america wouldn't fit.
Deal Fanatic
User avatar
Jan 9, 2011
6445 posts
6624 upvotes
Vancouver
martydxb wrote: Interesting information...
On another note, I'll surprised middle eastern countries such as United Arab Emirates or Kuwait did not make it.
While the Middle East is technically in Asia on a purely physiographical basis, physical geography is hardly the yardstick used to define Asia these days. I mean, who really thinks of Qatar, Israel, or even Russia when someone mentions Asia? Even including India is a bit of a stretch for many.
Member
Jul 5, 2010
322 posts
125 upvotes
Off course all those countries are in Asia? You seem to be confusing Far East with Asia.

Turkey is famous for being 1% in Europe and 99 in Asia.

More than 2/3 of Russia is in Asia. Indian sub continent is in Asia, it’s called South Asia. People of sub continent are called south Asians.

Your definition of Asia seems to be straight out of Markham.
Kiraly wrote: While the Middle East is technically in Asia on a purely physiographical basis, physical geography is hardly the yardstick used to define Asia these days. I mean, who really thinks of Qatar, Israel, or even Russia when someone mentions Asia? Even including India is a bit of a stretch for many.
Deal Addict
Jun 10, 2008
1075 posts
126 upvotes
chicu1981 wrote: ...
Your definition of Asia seems to be straight out of Markham.
Or maybe even South Carolina - this came to my mind :) -

Deal Expert
Feb 29, 2008
23546 posts
2855 upvotes
Montreal
Kiraly wrote: While the Middle East is technically in Asia on a purely physiographical basis, physical geography is hardly the yardstick used to define Asia these days.
Physical geography is the only yardstick used to define Asia.
Member
Nov 25, 2009
355 posts
127 upvotes
Terrace
What are those benefits that are so high?

Top