Which car should I buy? CX-9, CRV or others?

KevinM56081 wrote: ↑ Everything smaller has a CVT these days it seems. I'm driving a '14 Rogue with a CVT. They are different at first. Many people remember and era of Nissans having issues and the stigma around the CVT has generally stuck. Honestly, I don't notice it, it doesn't bother me. I change the fluid every couple years.

You're crossing 2 segments here. The RAV and the CRV (and I'll throw the CX-5) are quite different from the CX-9 and Pilot (and I'll include the Highlander since you mentioned the RX-350). The bigger of what you included do have a 3rd row, but don't count on using it often, for larger people, or for long distances. If that's the intent, buy a van. Also see you're grabbing at the upper level trims for all of these - is this a hard must, or can you work without some of the bling to bring the price down, or get you into something newer or lower mileage.

ldovale wrote: ↑ I'm in the process of transferring my 2018 Nissan Rogue S FWD. I decided to own a vehicle so getting something that will last is my priority. I was surprised by the CR-V isn't bad at all. Quieter than the Nissan and a bit faster.

I've always bought the lowest trim ever and I would like to have more comfort from now on so would like to add at least leather seats and a sun roof.

The difference between a 2018 CR-V EX-L and a Touring isn't too much probably $1000 but you get panoramic sunroof and better finish.
The Highlander is a nice car but price is too high for my perspective. I would buy a new one only if I had the change. Toyota holds its value like crazy so not worth to pursue one at this moment.

The Lexus is just my preferred car but most likely I won't buy it as it's higher than my budget.

Mazda CX-5 I believe is too small for me. I'm passing the Nissan because of the size so that's why I'm considering the CX-9 rather than the CX-5.
My concern is long term on this car. Rust and engine but I think they made a lot of improvements this last generation. Just wondering if a 2018 CX-9 will last for another 5 years if driven daily.

ldovale wrote: ↑ Hey folks,

Time to purchase for a used car for my family but there are so many options...
I just want make the right decision and would appreciate your insights.
Looking for a crossover/ mid-size SUV as my main car.
Have a family with 2 lil kids (3yo and 1yo) and I would like to find a sweet spot between drivability and space/ comfort.

This week I tested a 2017 CX-9 Signature, a 2018 Honda CR-V Touring and a 2016 Honda Pilot Touring.
All are good cars, I liked the Mazda the most but I'm not sure about reliability and long term "duration".
The Honda CR-V is the smallest with 2 row seats only but it's newer and has all features although has the weakest engine and CVT.
The Pilot is a nice one, big, V6 but it's over of my budget ($30k) a little bit and older. I found a nice one but it seems that it was never rust proofed and underneath is all rusty so I guess that won't last too long.

My dream is a RX-350 even though it's a little big higher my budget but it's been hard to find one below $35k.

Toyota RAV4 I would buy only the new model 2019+ but it's over $30k and I would buy an used compact suv for over 30 grant.

Let me know your thoughts. Appreciated.

tim-x wrote: ↑ No love for the minivan? Great mileage, theyre comfortable, and tonnes of space for the kiddos + luggage. Used Sienna or Odyssey can be had for under 30k.

Good luck in your search.

ldovale wrote: ↑ I hear you on the minivan. It's tempting but I rather sacrifice a bit of space towards performance, that's why CX-9 is in my radar.

Thank you.