Home & Garden

Do I leave the thermostat fan switch in Auto with a variable speed furnace?

  • Last Updated:
  • Mar 9th, 2022 3:30 pm
[OP]
Moderator
User avatar
Sep 30, 2001
29664 posts
9223 upvotes
Toronto

Do I leave the thermostat fan switch in Auto with a variable speed furnace?

I'm having a new 2 stage furnace installed with a variable speed motor (it wasn't what I originally purchased but it's 2022 and nothing goes to plan now days).

One thing I'm confused about is the relationship between the blower motor and the fan selector on the thermostat. Do I leave the fan selector in 'Auto' and let the furnace control when the fan should kick in? Also with these type of furnaces (in this case a Trane) does the fan run 24/7, just at varying speeds depending on how much cooling/heating is required?
Be kind and civil with one another
11 replies
Deal Addict
User avatar
May 28, 2009
1514 posts
498 upvotes
Ottawa
MrDisco wrote:
One thing I'm confused about is the relationship between the blower motor and the fan selector on the thermostat. Do I leave the fan selector in 'Auto' and let the furnace control when the fan should kick in? Also with these type of furnaces (in this case a Trane) does the fan run 24/7, just at varying speeds depending on how much cooling/heating is required?
if you leave in auto the fan comes in when the furnace/ac kick in,
if you leave it in the ON position then the fan is on irrespective of whether the furnace/ac in working.

some newer thermostats have a Circulate mode. my honeywell has this. this turns the fan on for about 20-30 mins i think every hr irrespective of whether the furnace/ac is on. I have mine set for this as I feel it even outs the airflow. my nbr has it set for ON during summer months. It all depends on how your comfort level is. with the DC motor the fan draws very little current so your hydro bill isnt affected too much
[OP]
Moderator
User avatar
Sep 30, 2001
29664 posts
9223 upvotes
Toronto
everylittlecent wrote: if you leave in auto the fan comes in when the furnace/ac kick in,
if you leave it in the ON position then the fan is on irrespective of whether the furnace/ac in working.

some newer thermostats have a Circulate mode. my honeywell has this. this turns the fan on for about 20-30 mins i think every hr irrespective of whether the furnace/ac is on. I have mine set for this as I feel it even outs the airflow. my nbr has it set for ON during summer months. It all depends on how your comfort level is. with the DC motor the fan draws very little current so your hydro bill isnt affected too much
I think what's tripping me up is the difference between a variable speed and a constant torque and how those relate to fan operation. My assumption is that if left in auto, the furnace will turn on the fan as needed, and adjust the fan speed accordingly, compared to a constant torque that will turn on the fan but it comes on at its full speed. Is that right?

I have a regular honeywell programmable TS which only has an auto/on selector. I guess that's my next question - do HE furnaces need a newer TS?
Be kind and civil with one another
Sr. Member
Dec 4, 2009
695 posts
687 upvotes
Fan speed is dependent on mode, AFAIK higher velocity when heating or cooling. In circ mode, not as fast…
Deal Addict
Jun 16, 2009
3915 posts
2522 upvotes
Woodbridge
It is a personal preference. I personally like the FAN to run 24X7 by selecting it "ON' from the thermostat. When fan is on "ON" it runs on continuous one speed irrespective of blower being variable or constant torque. Blower ramps up / down only when heat or cool is ON.
By having blower continuously ON without heat / cool cycle it balances the temperature through out the house and you have more consistent temp besides lesser stale air. If you add a little baby oil spray or any other fragrance on the filter, it gives an excellent results of freshness throughout at the min cost.
MrDisco wrote: I'm having a new 2 stage furnace installed with a variable speed motor (it wasn't what I originally purchased but it's 2022 and nothing goes to plan now days).

One thing I'm confused about is the relationship between the blower motor and the fan selector on the thermostat. Do I leave the fan selector in 'Auto' and let the furnace control when the fan should kick in? Also with these type of furnaces (in this case a Trane) does the fan run 24/7, just at varying speeds depending on how much cooling/heating is required?
Deal Addict
Jun 16, 2009
3915 posts
2522 upvotes
Woodbridge
If your basement is unfinished and you can have the new wires run ( 18/5 or 18/6). 18/5 will eliminate the need of Common makers for Nest / Ecobee tstats. By having 18/6 wire, you can control stages from your thermostat ( you do not lose much if you don't atleast IMHO).
Do you "NEED" a new thermostat for newer furnace ? Answer is NO.
MrDisco wrote: I think what's tripping me up is the difference between a variable speed and a constant torque and how those relate to fan operation. My assumption is that if left in auto, the furnace will turn on the fan as needed, and adjust the fan speed accordingly, compared to a constant torque that will turn on the fan but it comes on at its full speed. Is that right?

I have a regular honeywell programmable TS which only has an auto/on selector. I guess that's my next question - do HE furnaces need a newer TS?
Deal Addict
User avatar
May 28, 2009
1514 posts
498 upvotes
Ottawa
MrDisco wrote: I think what's tripping me up is the difference between a variable speed and a constant torque and how those relate to fan operation. My assumption is that if left in auto, the furnace will turn on the fan as needed, and adjust the fan speed accordingly, compared to a constant torque that will turn on the fan but it comes on at its full speed. Is that right?

I have a regular honeywell programmable TS which only has an auto/on selector. I guess that's my next question - do HE furnaces need a newer TS?
i think youre correct in your assumption.

most thermostats dont have the CIRC function its basically ON or AUTO. you dont need a new thermostat but if in the future you do this is a good option to have IMHO
Temp. Banned
Jun 24, 2015
7649 posts
2507 upvotes
0 downvotes
newlyborn wrote: It is a personal preference. I personally like the FAN to run 24X7 by selecting it "ON' from the thermostat. When fan is on "ON" it runs on continuous one speed irrespective of blower being variable or constant torque. Blower ramps up / down only when heat or cool is ON.
By having blower continuously ON without heat / cool cycle it balances the temperature through out the house and you have more consistent temp besides lesser stale air. If you add a little baby oil spray or any other fragrance on the filter, it gives an excellent results of freshness throughout at the min cost.
what about people who open their windows in the summer for fresh air? is it advisable to keep the fan running when you open all your windows or does that waste hydro and ineffective?
Supermarket worker at Fortino's
I'm Not a Wise Guy but more of a Good Fella~!
Drive an Escalade
Deal Addict
Jun 16, 2009
3915 posts
2522 upvotes
Woodbridge
Fresh air can never be substituted with any technology.
Leaving the fan ON with windows open will not make the needed impact.
GoodFellaz wrote: what about people who open their windows in the summer for fresh air? is it advisable to keep the fan running when you open all your windows or does that waste hydro and ineffective?
Temp. Banned
Jun 24, 2015
7649 posts
2507 upvotes
0 downvotes
what exactly does that mean "not make the needed impact" is it a good idea to open windows all day long in the spring when you leave the furnace setting to Fan Always On? or is it a BAD IDEA? everyone tells us to keep the fan always running, but doesnt the windows open do the exact same thing in the spring/summer time if we need fresh air?
Supermarket worker at Fortino's
I'm Not a Wise Guy but more of a Good Fella~!
Drive an Escalade
Deal Addict
User avatar
May 28, 2009
1514 posts
498 upvotes
Ottawa
GoodFellaz wrote: what exactly does that mean "not make the needed impact" is it a good idea to open windows all day long in the spring when you leave the furnace setting to Fan Always On? or is it a BAD IDEA? everyone tells us to keep the fan always running, but doesnt the windows open do the exact same thing in the spring/summer time if we need fresh air?
just think out loud as i have no scientific evidence. we do open the windows to get in fresh air but also have the fan run for about an hr or so. the reason being we typically open the upstairs windows and dont know whether the air in the basement is actually being replaced. so by turning on the fan, the basement air is rotated.
Temp. Banned
Jun 24, 2015
7649 posts
2507 upvotes
0 downvotes
Does your basement have a door? why not keep it open? air will eventually flow, and basements have windows too, no? well mine does
Supermarket worker at Fortino's
I'm Not a Wise Guy but more of a Good Fella~!
Drive an Escalade

Top