Home & Garden

Gas or Induction Stove?

  • Last Updated:
  • Apr 18th, 2022 10:34 pm
Tags:
[OP]
Deal Addict
Mar 22, 2017
2769 posts
3863 upvotes
West GTA

Gas or Induction Stove?

I’m redoing my kitchen (currently has an older electric stove on a 30 amp breaker) and am looking at appliances for the upgrade. I’ve been debating between induction and gas, and I’m wondering if people here could give their feedback and advice to help me decide! I’m sure it’s a divisive question ha but I’m struggling and could really do with some help!

I do have some circumstances that might weigh on things.

I have 100A service to the house with an old, full panel and either a new electric or induction would likely require an upgrade to the circuit to 40A (from 30A) and possibly require an upgrade of service to 200A (I don’t have much but I am cautious about a dryer, AC, fridge and stove all on at once, not sure if this matters, I have LED everywhere and gas furnace/heater, have been told likely okay though pushing it a bit). While this might be required anyways when electric cars become the standard, it’s pretty steep to potentially upgrade the service, panel and run a new circuit to the kitchen.

Obviously if I went gas I’d avoid the electric upgrade for now.

I do however have a small kid (and considering more), and gas worries me from a safety perspective. Kids like to play with knobs and gas turned on seems dangerous, both from fumes and fire. Induction isn’t as dangerous given the element doesn’t heat up on its own and there is no exhaust. Child locks require diligence and there are of course risks while the appliance is in use.

Im also somewhat worried from an overall health perspective, and some research indicates that gas can cause meaningful indoor air pollution. Powerful venting is a must and it’s still perhaps an issue.

For cooking performance, I don’t know. Induction is likely the fastest at boiling water, and heats up the kitchen less given all the energy goes into the pan. Gas is celebrated by a lot of experienced chefs. Induction if you’re unlucky can cause some buzzing, though it seems unpredictable and depends on the stove, pans and wiring. Electric ovens seem a bit better-liked than gas. Gas is a pain to clean and induction is easy. I’ve read that induction seems less reliable as a technology than gas. I’d probably buy new pans for induction, but likely would buy new ones regardless. Aesthetically it’s subjective, gas is more dramatic and induction a bit more sleek/modern. Induction is neat from a gadget perspective.

What do you think?
66 replies
Deal Expert
User avatar
Feb 11, 2007
20300 posts
24093 upvotes
GTA
I'd never go for gas. There's really no positives other than the look and that some old snobs think they're better. Induction (or resistive) is better in almost every way. Cleaning, health/fumes, control, no gas line to run, gas isn't going to get cheaper, and I suspect it's popularity will continue to decline in the future.
If the women don't find you handsome, they should at least find you handy.
Deal Addict
Nov 8, 2005
3233 posts
2833 upvotes
I have a gas stove, and although I love cooking on it, it's a nightmare to keep clean. Induction stoves just have too many positives and so few drawbacks. My next stove will be induction fo sure.
Deal Addict
User avatar
Aug 5, 2003
2605 posts
507 upvotes
North York
engineered wrote: I'd never go for gas. There's really no positives other than the look and that some old snobs think they're better. Induction (or resistive) is better in almost every way. Cleaning, health/fumes, control, no gas line to run, gas isn't going to get cheaper, and I suspect it's popularity will continue to decline in the future.
so gas price will go up at some point in the future, what about electricity? (guess it doesn't count, because it's already expensive?)

We have a gas/electric combo, if we didn't have it we'd go induction, but a regular old coil or smooth top glass - no thanks.
Deal Addict
User avatar
Oct 9, 2010
3138 posts
1321 upvotes
Windsor
If cost is irrelevant: induction. The amount you'll need to spend to get something that works as well as even the cheapest gas stove (aka: no annoying issues) is substantial. The new wire + box upgrade (your house is probably good for 125A) will also not be cheap, but you'll get a lot more breakers, so that's good. Your hood will be good enough. An induction range is also far more likely to fail than a gas one. Induction compatible pots are a must. The heat-plate for non-induction cookware works like garbage.

For gas, you can buy the biggest piece of garbage and it will work just as well as something fancy. Can't comment on how much the gas line will be, but probably a lot cheaper than the electrical upgrade. Your hood might need an upgrade, but probably not.

It looks like you understand a lot of the pros/cons. I think you just need to pick. I have a fancy induction upstairs, an a side-of-the-road gas downstairs. Cooking wise, they tie. Cleaning wise, induction rocks. Knowing my $6k induction oven is a failed $2 part away from being a paperweight is not comforting.
One who is offended by truth, has no place among those who seek wisdom.
Jr. Member
Feb 6, 2018
122 posts
36 upvotes
I prefer an induction stove because it is easier to clean and makes water boiling and preheating spooky fast.
Deal Expert
User avatar
Feb 11, 2007
20300 posts
24093 upvotes
GTA
cliff wrote: so gas price will go up at some point in the future, what about electricity? (guess it doesn't count, because it's already expensive?)

We have a gas/electric combo, if we didn't have it we'd go induction, but a regular old coil or smooth top glass - no thanks.
Both will go up, but we can expect carbon pricing to increase gas costs. But either way I don't thing gas/electricity costs are significant for the amount of cooking most do.
Induction is expensive, but the people seem to get fancy gas ranges that are at least as expensive. If cost is a problem, then I'd still go resistive over gas, mostly for cleaning, but also for safety reasons.
If the women don't find you handsome, they should at least find you handy.
Deal Addict
User avatar
May 6, 2010
1067 posts
421 upvotes
Richmond Hill
only 60% of electricity produced from non-carbon generating sources.
hybrid system is interesting
Image
Deal Expert
User avatar
Jul 5, 2004
27196 posts
6521 upvotes
I really like my gas stove. I understand the advantages of induction, but if I was to buy a new stove, it would be a gas one again.
Banned
Jun 4, 2020
1634 posts
1745 upvotes
Clarington, ON
We've been on induction for about 2 months now. Some considerations I made:
  • I didn't have gas run to the area
  • My range hood is a recirc - it doesn't vent to the outside
  • Cleaning - my sister has a gas stove, and anytime you have the slightest boil over it's just a pain.
Re: electrical concerns. The world has a stove, dryer, fridge, A/C. If you can't bump your stove to the current 40A standard, how are they building houses these days with 100A service. Breaker wise, it will be out with the old 30A and in with the new 40A. Consider that the panel may be dated though and that finding breakers could be difficult. Also, with respect to upgrade to 200A, check and the conduits that enter your meter. If you have a 2" conduit and an 1-1/4", you should have 200A from the transformer to the meter. The feed from the meter to the panel would have to be upgraded though (may be a short run, may not...).

Re: Buzzing. We bought a Frigidaire Gallery as well as Zwilling Sol 2 cookware, a new kettle, etc. I hear some buzz when I'm on high or power boil. Outside of that things are quiet.
Deal Expert
User avatar
Feb 8, 2014
28885 posts
12560 upvotes
Socially Distanced
Induction, 150%
There are several threads about induction vs gas, the search feature can kick them out.

Oh and i have a gas range that came with this place, i haven't used the stove in months (maybe since last year) because i bought an induction hotplate from Ikea. Its that superior.
In fact in Rand McNally they wear hats on their feet and hamburgers eat people
Deal Fanatic
User avatar
Dec 4, 2009
8337 posts
4271 upvotes
Induction
"I'm a bit upset. I've been grab by the back without any alert and lubrification"
Lucky
Member
Jul 4, 2021
376 posts
197 upvotes
GTA
Sounds like you might be leaning towards Induction based on safety concerns (kids playing with knobs etc).

Personally, we bought induction due to a) easier clean/maintain, b) trying to avoid gas lines as much as is possible eg leaks etc, and c) as you said, we had a kid that would play with everything...
[OP]
Deal Addict
Mar 22, 2017
2769 posts
3863 upvotes
West GTA
golferbowl wrote: Sounds like you might be leaning towards Induction based on safety concerns (kids playing with knobs etc).

Personally, we bought induction due to a) easier clean/maintain, b) trying to avoid gas lines as much as is possible eg leaks etc, and c) as you said, we had a kid that would play with everything...
You're right, I am leaning that way - I'm however looking at a steep ticket to go induction, and am aware that it doesn't have the greatest reputation for reliability and can come with some quirks (at outlined in the OP). Gas is easier to install and does seem to be fairly well-reviewed as well by a lot of serious cooks, though it could be a familiarity bias. Doing all the electrical work for induction is going to potentially be thousands over gas, so I have to psych myself up for it and wanted to make sure that this was really worth it.
Deal Expert
User avatar
Feb 11, 2007
20300 posts
24093 upvotes
GTA
grumble wrote: You're right, I am leaning that way - I'm however looking at a steep ticket to go induction, and am aware that it doesn't have the greatest reputation for reliability and can come with some quirks (at outlined in the OP). Gas is easier to install and does seem to be fairly well-reviewed as well by a lot of serious cooks, though it could be a familiarity bias. Doing all the electrical work for induction is going to potentially be thousands over gas, so I have to psych myself up for it and wanted to make sure that this was really worth it.
Do you have a gas line already? Otherwise running one is also pretty pricey and probably more than running a 40A circuit. But if you have to upgrade your panel, that's where your cost will be. I doubt you need to though. It's unlikely that your appliances will all be running at their max rated amperage at the same time. I think it would only make sense if you also want to install 40AEV chargers.
My house has also has [email protected] service (which is [email protected]) and I have 30A AC, 30A dryer and 2x40A stoves. I could go over if everything was on, but even your current situation can go over if you use the AC/Dryer/Stove at max power together.
If the women don't find you handsome, they should at least find you handy.
Deal Guru
User avatar
Mar 13, 2004
13513 posts
5142 upvotes
Ontario
I would only go for Gas personally and the reason for that is when the power goes out you can still cook food and feed your family. I remember a few years ago we had no power for 1-2 days in the summer and I could see people having issues with food (people were posting on social media) since nothing worked and they could not cook anything, meanwhile i was making pasta and steak haha that alone wins it for me.
Not only that but electronics are known to fail, so in my opinion you have a greater chance of one of the other other ovens to malfunction and have issues. Oh and I think gas is cheaper at least for now.
[OP]
Deal Addict
Mar 22, 2017
2769 posts
3863 upvotes
West GTA
sickcars wrote: I would only go for Gas personally and the reason for that is when the power goes out you can still cook food and feed your family. I remember a few years ago we had no power for 1-2 days in the summer and I could see people having issues with food (people were posting on social media) since nothing worked and they could not cook anything, meanwhile i was making pasta and steak haha that alone wins it for me.
Not only that but electronics are known to fail, so in my opinion you have a greater chance of one of the other other ovens to malfunction and have issues. Oh and I think gas is cheaper at least for now.
No question induction is less reliable, gas is really simple tech and is built sturdily given the fuel source involved. Induction has lots of electronics and many of them are temperature-sensitive. If reliability was my only consideration I'd go gas all the way. I'm just trying to weigh that against the other factors (safety, utility, health, etc.) and get the best overall one for my situation. I didn't think about the ability to cook while power's out - it's rare, but it can happen and would be nice to be able to cook food in a blackout. Great point! The cost issue doesn't phase me much, it probably wouldn't be more than a few bucks a month difference in fuel costs, but agreed gas has the edge there for now.
Deal Addict
Dec 4, 2011
2410 posts
2537 upvotes
Montréal
I could have gas but chose induction when it came time to replace our range and never looked back. Most of my chef friends in Montreal prefer induction over gas as well for all the reasons above. One advantage for gas still is wok-style cooking (I am generalising) where you need nuclear levels of heat for it to work if that matters to you

@sickcars that is what the BBQ is for! ;) Your point is valid however.
Deal Guru
User avatar
Mar 13, 2004
13513 posts
5142 upvotes
Ontario
haha yes true BBQ would help, but if its in the winter due to an ice storm you may not want to go outside and bbq ;)
admiralackbar wrote: I could have gas but chose induction when it came time to replace our range and never looked back. Most of my chef friends in Montreal prefer induction over gas as well for all the reasons above. One advantage for gas still is wok-style cooking (I am generalising) where you need nuclear levels of heat for it to work if that matters to you

@sickcars that is what the BBQ is for! ;) Your point is valid however.
[OP]
Deal Addict
Mar 22, 2017
2769 posts
3863 upvotes
West GTA
engineered wrote: Do you have a gas line already? Otherwise running one is also pretty pricey and probably more than running a 40A circuit. But if you have to upgrade your panel, that's where your cost will be. I doubt you need to though. It's unlikely that your appliances will all be running at their max rated amperage at the same time. I think it would only make sense if you also want to install 40AEV chargers.
My house has also has [email protected] service (which is [email protected]) and I have 30A AC, 30A dryer and 2x40A stoves. I could go over if everything was on, but even your current situation can go over if you use the AC/Dryer/Stove at max power together.
I don't, but I have pretty easy access (unfinished crawlspace) so can likely get the gas line put in fairly easily. I'm happy to hear that you have a lot of high draw appliances and have no issues with 100A service - if I can avoid a service upgrade it'd be great news, though I'll likely have to do the panel at least if I go induction as it's both ancient and full. I think people are aware that electric chargers will eventually be a thing, so maybe worth it to upgrade while I'm at it, but I have no imminent need and it's expensive. I appreciate your input and I'll chat with an electrician friend as well to see about options.

Everything about this is expensive!

Top

Thread Information

There is currently 1 user viewing this thread. (0 members and 1 guest)