Automotive

Need Advice: Dent found on a rental that I still have... Help!

  • Last Updated:
  • Mar 20th, 2013 10:42 pm
[OP]
Newbie
Apr 26, 2012
57 posts
6 upvotes
Toronto

Need Advice: Dent found on a rental that I still have... Help!

I rented a car on the weekend for a couple of weeks. I did the walkthrough and didn't see anything, I signed the form and I was on my way. Yesterday when I walked by my car in the parking lot I noticed a dent on the front bumper near the tire. This clearly looks like it would happen if someone drove over a curb or something (it's too low for another car to do it), so I know this didn't happen while it's been with me.

What should I do? I have insurance through my credit card, but at this point if I hold on to the car and return it 2 weeks later - it is likely the rental agency is going to ding me for it if hasn't been reported previously.

Any advice??
23 replies
Banned
Jan 11, 2004
19816 posts
575 upvotes
You have insurance with your credit card, don't worry about it. Inform your credit card (who will give you contact for the insurance underwriters ) and let them know. when you return the car, either a) car rental will deal directly with insurance or b) charge you later with a bill/invoice and you will then submit to insurance who will reimburse you.
[OP]
Newbie
Apr 26, 2012
57 posts
6 upvotes
Toronto
gilboman wrote: You have insurance with your credit card, don't worry about it. Inform your credit card (who will give you contact for the insurance underwriters ) and let them know. when you return the car, either a) car rental will deal directly with insurance or b) charge you later with a bill/invoice and you will then submit to insurance who will reimburse you.
Thanks for the speedy response.

I feel like I sholdn't have to deal with this if I didn't create the problem.

So you suggest waiting until I return the car before I inform the credit card company? When I do the walkthrough and the agent doesn't notice the dent and I sign off on it, is there any way they will ding me later? I need to inform the credit card company within 48 hours after the rental period is over. Otherwise the insurance is void.
Deal Addict
Dec 19, 2008
1559 posts
1120 upvotes
Do the post-rental inspection and see if they take a note of the dent. If they don't make sure to keep a copy of that inspection form. If they do then I guess you'll have to go through insurance.
Deal Expert
User avatar
May 10, 2005
37413 posts
11929 upvotes
Ottawa
sphinx666 wrote: Thanks for the speedy response.

I feel like I sholdn't have to deal with this if I didn't create the problem.

So you suggest waiting until I return the car before I inform the credit card company? When I do the walkthrough and the agent doesn't notice the dent and I sign off on it, is there any way they will ding me later? I need to inform the credit card company within 48 hours after the rental period is over. Otherwise the insurance is void.
Actually, you did create the problem. It happened during your rental period, therefore your responsibility.
They can come back at you for months after. The fine print will indicate how many months. On one occasion, They tried to ding me 6 months after the rental. There were circumstances involved and I did not get charged but National had a 12 month period in their fine print.
“Those people who think they know everything are a great annoyance to those of us who do.”
[OP]
Newbie
Apr 26, 2012
57 posts
6 upvotes
Toronto
Pete_Coach wrote: Actually, you did create the problem. It happened during your rental period, therefore your responsibility.
They can come back at you for months after. The fine print will indicate how many months. On one occasion, They tried to ding me 6 months after the rental. There were circumstances involved and I did not get charged but National had a 12 month period in their fine print.
There is no way this happened during my rental period. It's obvious that this a curb run-up type dent and I didn't do it. I would understand if the dent was higher then I could say that for sure perhaps someone hit the car while it was parked. But it's not possible.

How do they prove that it happened during car rental period?

So, what advice are you giving me at this point?
Deal Expert
User avatar
May 10, 2005
37413 posts
11929 upvotes
Ottawa
sphinx666 wrote: There is no way this happened during my rental period. It's obvious that this a curb run-up type dent and I didn't do it. I would understand if the dent was higher then I could say that for sure perhaps someone hit the car while it was parked. But it's not possible.

How do they prove that it happened during car rental period?

So, what advice are you giving me at this point?
I guess my point is, was it noted during your pre-rental inspection? No, well then, it can be attributed to you. All they have to prove is that the damage is there now and it was not before.
Advice, well, there is no advice really, you can hope the dent is not noticed. If it is, argue with them that it was there and see if you can win the argument. If you lose, hope that your insurance will cover it, including the loss of use that they always seem to add on. There are stories and they are not unusual.
http://www.elliott.org/blog/how-to-win- ... laim-game/
http://seattletimes.com/html/travel/201 ... ter26.html
http://www.elliott.org/blog/is-the-car- ... travelers/
“Those people who think they know everything are a great annoyance to those of us who do.”
Deal Addict
Dec 19, 2008
1559 posts
1120 upvotes
Pete_Coach wrote: Actually, you did create the problem. It happened during your rental period, therefore your responsibility.
They can come back at you for months after. The fine print will indicate how many months. On one occasion, They tried to ding me 6 months after the rental. There were circumstances involved and I did not get charged but National had a 12 month period in their fine print.
Did they notify you about the damage within the week you returned it? And was it cosmetic or an internal problem? Under their TOS they state:

NOTICE OF RIGHT TO INSPECT DAMAGE

If the car is damaged, we may not collect any amount for the damage unless you, or an authorized driver against whom we claim liability, have been promptly notified of your and your insurers' right to inspect the unrepaired car within two working days after we were notified of the damage. If you request, we must also give you copies of two estimates we have obtained from repair shops regarding any damage claim.

When working at Budget, we did pre and post inspections for every rental. If something wasn't caught during the post inspection we did not try to claim damage (if it was only cosmetic).
[OP]
Newbie
Apr 26, 2012
57 posts
6 upvotes
Toronto
ditachan wrote: Did they notify you about the damage within the week you returned it? And was it cosmetic or an internal problem? Under their TOS they state:

NOTICE OF RIGHT TO INSPECT DAMAGE

If the car is damaged, we may not collect any amount for the damage unless you, or an authorized driver against whom we claim liability, have been promptly notified of your and your insurers' right to inspect the unrepaired car within two working days after we were notified of the damage. If you request, we must also give you copies of two estimates we have obtained from repair shops regarding any damage claim.

When working at Budget, we did pre and post inspections for every rental. If something wasn't caught during the post inspection we did not try to claim damage (if it was only cosmetic).
This is with Enterprise. My worry is that they will come after me after I return the car and then it will be too late to claim it from the credit card insurance company.

Does anyone think it's a good idea to call them now and report that this is what I have found? Perhaps they look at the reports and see if was a known issue and I can put this to rest, otherwise I risk them coming after me later (it's cometic). I'm reading too may horror stories that Enterprise is comign back 6 months later and sending people bills for dents, etc.
Deal Addict
User avatar
Jun 10, 2011
2346 posts
905 upvotes
Etobicoke
Pete_Coach wrote: Actually, you did create the problem. It happened during your rental period, therefore your responsibility.
They can come back at you for months after. The fine print will indicate how many months. On one occasion, They tried to ding me 6 months after the rental. There were circumstances involved and I did not get charged but National had a 12 month period in their fine print.
I've had huge issues with National in the past too. My rental was hit in a parking lot. I notified my bank's CC insurance about the accident. But I had to deal with National in person for the insurance. It was a long and painful process.
Deal Expert
User avatar
May 10, 2005
37413 posts
11929 upvotes
Ottawa
ditachan wrote: Did they notify you about the damage within the week you returned it? And was it cosmetic or an internal problem? Under their TOS they state:

NOTICE OF RIGHT TO INSPECT DAMAGE

If the car is damaged, we may not collect any amount for the damage unless you, or an authorized driver against whom we claim liability, have been promptly notified of your and your insurers' right to inspect the unrepaired car within two working days after we were notified of the damage. If you request, we must also give you copies of two estimates we have obtained from repair shops regarding any damage claim.

When working at Budget, we did pre and post inspections for every rental. If something wasn't caught during the post inspection we did not try to claim damage (if it was only cosmetic).
You quoted me so, are you asking me these questions?
Regardless, I think that every car rental company has slightly different policies.
durrsak wrote: I've had huge issues with National in the past too. My rental was hit in a parking lot. I notified my bank's CC insurance about the accident. But I had to deal with National in person for the insurance. It was a long and painful process.
To me, this occurred while I was away on business. I was charged by National for damage to the rental car on my credit card about 4 or 5 months after the rental. I called and was given the runaround about my obligation and the fine print on the rental agreement and how the damage was underneath the car (?) and so on. I told them they could not charge me and they faxed me the portion of the contract that indicated they had up to a year to recover loses. I was P'd and contacted my credit card company. They were also not helpful except they were going to check what coverage I had.
So, I was complaining about it at work and a co-worker mentioned he was dinged too. On this particular occasion I was away with a number of colleagues from all over the Country and we rented cars from the airport and train station and in town locations. This started a conversation and we checked with other folks that were at the meetings and low and behold, there were 3 other guys that got dinged. We contacted our corporate credit card fraud office and although we never heard back, charges on the card were dropped and we were told never to rent from National again.
“Those people who think they know everything are a great annoyance to those of us who do.”
Deal Expert
User avatar
Oct 5, 2008
19810 posts
16614 upvotes
Toronto
sphinx666 wrote: Thanks for the speedy response.

I feel like I sholdn't have to deal with this if I didn't create the problem.So you suggest waiting until I return the car before I inform the credit card company? When I do the walkthrough and the agent doesn't notice the dent and I sign off on it, is there any way they will ding me later? I need to inform the credit card company within 48 hours after the rental period is over. Otherwise the insurance is void.
Actually you did by not noticing the damage when you did your "inspection".
Deal Fanatic
User avatar
Mar 30, 2004
5571 posts
3405 upvotes
Durham Region
sphinx666 wrote: This is with Enterprise. My worry is that they will come after me after I return the car and then it will be too late to claim it from the credit card insurance company.
It won't be. Just make sure you keep all of your documentation. Enterprise will likely charge you for the damages, and your card company will reimburse you.

What credit card company is this?
[OP]
Newbie
Apr 26, 2012
57 posts
6 upvotes
Toronto
CorSter wrote: It won't be. Just make sure you keep all of your documentation. Enterprise will likely charge you for the damages, and your card company will reimburse you.

What credit card company is this?
CIBC Aventura - I think their policy is 48 hours
Deal Fanatic
Jun 26, 2009
5514 posts
5425 upvotes
Get a spare key made. Drive to Jane/Finch area Tim Hortons, go inside (car running, Window open, spare key in ignition), return to your car one hour later, look for it, call the cops, give them the original key, call the insurance... easier than paying for stupid dent...
Deal Addict
User avatar
Nov 14, 2006
2614 posts
1967 upvotes
Waterloo
If they find damage when you return your vehicle, they may pull the inspection report from the last 2-3 times the car was rented out (depending on the company). If the damage was noted on any of those inspections, you're off the hook. If not, you'll have to start a claim with your insurance company.

Pay closer attention next time :)
Congratulations!
Today is YOUR day.
You're off to great places!
You're off and away!
Deal Addict
Dec 24, 2002
2934 posts
622 upvotes
Ajax
Enterprise I find is pretty leniant. I used to work for a rental co. way back. They will check prior agreements . Don't go crazy over this especially if your cc has coverage.

Top

Topic Information

There is currently 1 user viewing this thread. (0 members and 1 guest)