Home & Garden

Please guide - difference between clad or tri ply stainless steel cookware and the on in the link.

  • Last Updated:
  • Jan 31st, 2023 3:14 pm
[OP]
Sr. Member
Jun 24, 2013
797 posts
1760 upvotes
Mississauga

Please guide - difference between clad or tri ply stainless steel cookware and the on in the link.

Please guide me - through the difference between clad or tri-ply stainless steel cookware and the one in the link.

https://www.walmart.ca/en/ip/t-fal-unli ... W4Y44RQD4P

is it good?- only pan is nonstick other pieces are stainless steel but not sure about the quality. if you can guide will be great.
14 replies
Deal Expert
Aug 22, 2006
29830 posts
15320 upvotes
Technically speaking a clad pan and tri ply are the same thing. Well not quite, tri ply is always cladded but not all cladded is tri ply. Some are 5 ply.
I think you're thinking of disc bottom which is what you linked.

A clad/tri ply pan has (usually) aluminum sandwiched between stainless steel.
A disc bottom is literally that: a disc on the bottom of stainless steel.

Cladded cookware is generally superior for a number of reasons but you're paying for it.

For $50 (assuming you can find it) it's a no brainer. But $200 regular price? That's laughable. Cough up the extra $100 and you can get the Kirkland 10 piece 5 ply.
Do you not have anything else to do rather than argue with strangers on the internet
Nope. That's why I'm on the internet arguing with strangers. If I had anything better to do I'd probably be doing it.
[OP]
Sr. Member
Jun 24, 2013
797 posts
1760 upvotes
Mississauga
death_hawk wrote: Technically speaking a clad pan and tri ply are the same thing. Well not quite, tri ply is always cladded but not all cladded is tri ply. Some are 5 ply.
I think you're thinking of disc bottom which is what you linked.

A clad/tri ply pan has (usually) aluminum sandwiched between stainless steel.
A disc bottom is literally that: a disc on the bottom of stainless steel.

Cladded cookware is generally superior for a number of reasons but you're paying for it.

For $50 (assuming you can find it) it's a no brainer. But $200 regular price? That's laughable. Cough up the extra $100 and you can get the Kirkland 10 piece 5 ply.
I already purchased and thinking now if good to keep or not... so looking for views-

Thank you
Member
User avatar
May 16, 2018
319 posts
266 upvotes
hennamomin wrote: I already purchased and thinking now if good to keep or not... so looking for views-

Thank you
The horse has kind of left the barn if you already purchased it ...
Have you used it ? How do you like it ?
[OP]
Sr. Member
Jun 24, 2013
797 posts
1760 upvotes
Mississauga
Patriotcdn wrote: The horse has kind of left the barn if you already purchased it ...
Have you used it ? How do you like it ?
no, I have not used it yet- as before i use want to make sure it is a better quality- as I have 90 days to return so, looking for reviews and cant find much online.
Moderator
May 28, 2012
12121 posts
4770 upvotes
Saskatoon
Personally I would go with the Kirkland set death_hawk mentions. The T-fal one in your link is disc bottom. Having cooked with higher end clad pots, I would never go back to disc bottom except for my huge stock pot. You have more even heat with clad type. When I made jam with a disc bottom dutch oven it would splatter hot jam all over the place...I get that a lot less with my All Clad. Consider what sizes of pots and pans you use the most...see if it's more economical to get a few pieces of good quality rather than a set with pieces you won't use.
Deal Addict
User avatar
Jun 3, 2010
1252 posts
843 upvotes
Richmond Hill
For me, the pots and pans (e.g. clad, cast iron Dutch ovens, carbon steel) that I have and use regularly today have all been a gradual step up from very basic aluminum pots and pans that I took from my parents when I first moved out.

I didn't start off with the good stuff because I didn't believe back then that the construction of the pan will make a difference. Of course I also did not have the $$$$ available to buy the good stuff. After I honed my cooking skills and was able to cook consistent quality with the pans I had, I bought my first All-Clad frying pan and it was then that I really saw the difference with what I was cooking.

So OP...how far along are you on your cooking journey? If you are just cooking for sustenance and you won't really care too much about cooking anything fancy or with any precision, then I would think the T-Fal set you linked is fine.

I started out with base level cookware and honed my skills over the years. I'm not a professional chef...not even an intermediate...Just a hobbyist that had upgraded individual kitchen items along the way when I gained the experience to use things properly. The last thing I wanted to do was to ruin some expensive item because I was using it wrong.

Clad cookware is good, but if you don't need it, you don't need it. My everyday non-stick frypan is still a T-Fal. It's simple and cheap. Eventually when the non-stick coating scratches up too much, I don't feel bad replacing it. I'm just cooking eggs, bacon and stuff like that on it. I don't need cladware to do that. I think you can think about this point.

One other thing I have figured out over the years....if you do not need to buy a SET...don't. Just buy the pot or pan you need. It may look more expensive because you are only buying one item...but if you don't need any of the other items...you are just keeping more pots and pans in your cupboards that you don't use and will eventually have to throw out anyway. But if you have zero pots and pans right now...a set makes sense to start you off.
[OP]
Sr. Member
Jun 24, 2013
797 posts
1760 upvotes
Mississauga
toram23901 wrote: For me, the pots and pans (e.g. clad, cast iron Dutch ovens, carbon steel) that I have and use regularly today have all been a gradual step up from very basic aluminum pots and pans that I took from my parents when I first moved out.

I didn't start off with the good stuff because I didn't believe back then that the construction of the pan will make a difference. Of course I also did not have the $$$$ available to buy the good stuff. After I honed my cooking skills and was able to cook consistent quality with the pans I had, I bought my first All-Clad frying pan and it was then that I really saw the difference with what I was cooking.

So OP...how far along are you on your cooking journey? If you are just cooking for sustenance and you won't really care too much about cooking anything fancy or with any precision, then I would think the T-Fal set you linked is fine.

I started out with base level cookware and honed my skills over the years. I'm not a professional chef...not even an intermediate...Just a hobbyist that had upgraded individual kitchen items along the way when I gained the experience to use things properly. The last thing I wanted to do was to ruin some expensive item because I was using it wrong.

Clad cookware is good, but if you don't need it, you don't need it. My everyday non-stick frypan is still a T-Fal. It's simple and cheap. Eventually when the non-stick coating scratches up too much, I don't feel bad replacing it. I'm just cooking eggs, bacon and stuff like that on it. I don't need cladware to do that. I think you can think about this point.

One other thing I have figured out over the years....if you do not need to buy a SET...don't. Just buy the pot or pan you need. It may look more expensive because you are only buying one item...but if you don't need any of the other items...you are just keeping more pots and pans in your cupboards that you don't use and will eventually have to throw out anyway. But if you have zero pots and pans right now...a set makes sense to start you off.
I appreciate your detailed reply. I cook every day- for my family and use aluminum pots so looking to replace them with a healthy option- i will check out clad pots- i am not a fan of nonstick ones and use such only for eggs.
I will wait and watch for a better deal on clad.

thank you.
Deal Expert
Aug 22, 2006
29830 posts
15320 upvotes
hennamomin wrote:
I already purchased and thinking now if good to keep or not... so looking for views-
I guess a better question now is how much did you pay?
$50? Keep it. Even if you do find a clad set later, $50 for a spare set for the holidays is still pretty damn good.
$200? How fast can you get on that horse that left the barn to go back to the store?

toram23901 wrote: I'm not a professional chef...
Fun fact: Most professional chefs use aluminum because it's cheap.
There's a few that use stainless clad but due to the cost it's only really in very high end restaurants or those that have started with a trust fund.
Some also use carbon steel but that's another breed too.
Aluminum is dominant.
Do you not have anything else to do rather than argue with strangers on the internet
Nope. That's why I'm on the internet arguing with strangers. If I had anything better to do I'd probably be doing it.
Deal Addict
User avatar
Jun 3, 2010
1252 posts
843 upvotes
Richmond Hill
death_hawk wrote: Fun fact: Most professional chefs use aluminum because it's cheap.
There's a few that use stainless clad but due to the cost it's only really in very high end restaurants or those that have started with a trust fund.
Some also use carbon steel but that's another breed too.
Aluminum is dominant.
Good to know...
[OP]
Sr. Member
Jun 24, 2013
797 posts
1760 upvotes
Mississauga
death_hawk wrote: I guess a better question now is how much did you pay?
$50? Keep it. Even if you do find a clad set later, $50 for a spare set for the holidays is still pretty damn good.
$200? How fast can you get on that horse that left the barn to go back to the store?




Fun fact: Most professional chefs use aluminum because it's cheap.
There's a few that use stainless clad but due to the cost it's only really in very high end restaurants or those that have started with a trust fund.
Some also use carbon steel but that's another breed too.
Aluminum is dominant.
I am RFD member paid 50 only... thanks
Deal Fanatic
Aug 31, 2010
7077 posts
6019 upvotes
hennamomin wrote: I am RFD member paid 50 only... thanks
For $50 it's a good set.

Especially if you don't know the difference already, you won't once you start using it.

Going with better quality clad pans will cost you much more than $50.

e.g. a kirkland 10 piece set is $500 - https://www.costco.ca/.product.100800604.html
Deal Expert
Aug 22, 2006
29830 posts
15320 upvotes
hennamomin wrote:
I am RFD member paid 50 only... thanks
I'd definitely keep it.
hvc wrote:
e.g. a kirkland 10 piece set is $500 - https://www.costco.ca/.product.100800604.html
Why'd you link the Kitchenaid at $500?
The Kirkland is $300 regular price with a price drop of $50 to $250 some time in the past:
https://www.costco.ca/kirkland-signatur ... 29551.html

$250 vs this set for $200? No brainer.
$250 vs this set for $50? Also a no brainer.
Do you not have anything else to do rather than argue with strangers on the internet
Nope. That's why I'm on the internet arguing with strangers. If I had anything better to do I'd probably be doing it.
Deal Fanatic
Aug 31, 2010
7077 posts
6019 upvotes
death_hawk wrote: I'd definitely keep it.



Why'd you link the Kitchenaid at $500?
The Kirkland is $300 regular price with a price drop of $50 to $250 some time in the past:
https://www.costco.ca/kirkland-signatur ... 29551.html

$250 vs this set for $200? No brainer.
$250 vs this set for $50? Also a no brainer.
Because I linked to kitchen aid instead of Kirkland and then adjusted my post to say $500 lol whoops. I was wondering why the price went up so much since last time I checked.

But yeah, point still stands.
Deal Addict
Mar 22, 2017
2580 posts
3508 upvotes
West GTA
T-Fal Unlimited I believe is a single-ply aluminum pan with an anodized exterior and a non-stick coating on the inside. It is induction compatible due to an embedded disc in the bottom. I find the plans flimsy and thin when I've picked them up, and non-stick layers, despite their claims, are not the best choice for everyday pans as the surfaces tend to scratch and degrade over time.

That being said, even a couple of mm of aluminum can make a pan a lot more even, so they'll likely outperform their weight in hand. Aluminum pans, especially thick ones (thicker than this) are quite even heating.

For example, take a Ninja Foodi Premium nonstick pan, 4.5mm of aluminum in base and a couple mm in the sides. Then look at the well-marketed All-Clad D3, 1.7mm of aluminum in the core. The Ninja Foodi nonstick pan is going to be way more even-heating. The clad pans are useful because their surfaces are bulletproof and you can cook anything on them, but they won't beat a thick aluminum pan for even cooking.

Top

Thread Information

There is currently 1 user viewing this thread. (0 members and 1 guest)