Locked: Proper Calculation of Having a phone on contract vs outright

Search this thread

Last Updated:
Jul 4th, 2016 2:50 pm

Tags:

None

Locked

Search this thread

Jun 27th, 2016 10:16 am

djemzine [OP]: Deal Expert; Jun 15, 2011; 43889 posts; 7527 upvotes

Jun 27th, 2016 10:16 am

Proper Calculation of Having a phone on contract vs outright

So I know there's been discussions where people prefer to sign up for a contract vs buying a phone outright, and that it works out to be cheaper either way. That being said, what is the exact calculation to use? I.e. to know if its cost effective in getting a phone on contract or outright?

Edit: This is a corporate plan. Plan is same regardless of contract or no contract. Contract term is 36 months vs 24 months.

Example - I shall use the iPhone SE (5SE) 16GB as an example.

a) Contract option

Plan - $40 voice + $10 data (unlimited with 10GB fair usage policy - flex rate). Max $56.50 taxes in a month
Contract term - 36 months
Contract price - $99 + taxes

Would the calculation be: $111.87 (for phone $99 + taxes) + $2034 ($56.50 x 36 months) = $2145.87 total cost of phone + monthly plan for length of 36 month term?

b) Outright option:

Plan - $40 voice + $10 data (unlimited with 10GB fair usage policy - flex rate). Max $56.50 taxes in a month
Outright price - $579 + taxes
Usage of phone non contract - Say lets say we use the phone for 36 months - Or does this not apply when calculating it?

Would the calculation be: $654.27 (for phone $579 + taxes) + $2034 ($56.50 x 36 months) = $2688.27

Therefore its cheaper to get the phone on contract?

Pros of no contract - factory unlocked iPhone - can use when traveling. Can leave Rogers if needed without any cancellation fees, etc.

Thanks

Blanka

17 replies

Jun 27th, 2016 10:26 am

JIB9022: Deal Addict; Feb 14, 2016; 1832 posts; 1222 upvotes

Jun 27th, 2016 10:26 am

Monthly fee cannot be same between contract option vs outright option;
contract option is always more expensive;
Monthly saving achieved by paying cheaper monthly plan offsets the outright cost in 2 years + getting unlocked phone etc

usually same plan (data, minutes) for BYOP and contract price differ by around 30-40 bucks at least; so ($30 savings per month x 24 = 720 savings total)
So leaving everything same, add 30 bucks to your contract calculation, and that should be about right

rogers minimum plan for contract is 80;

Jun 27th, 2016 10:30 am

djemzine [OP]: Deal Expert; Jun 15, 2011; 43889 posts; 7527 upvotes

Jun 27th, 2016 10:30 am

JIB9022 wrote: ↑Monthly fee cannot be same between contract option vs outright option;
contract option is always more expensive;
Monthly saving achieved by paying cheaper monthly plan offsets the outright cost in 2 years + getting unlocked phone etc

usually same plan (data, minutes) for BYOP and contract price differ by around 30-40 bucks at least; so ($30 savings per month x 24 = 720 savings total)
So leaving everything same, add 30 bucks to your contract calculation, and that should be about right

Not with my Corporate plan. Monthly fee is same regardless of contract or no contract/month to month/if bringing my own phone.

Blanka

Jun 27th, 2016 10:32 am

cgtlky: Deal Fanatic; Jan 31, 2006; 7725 posts; 2131 upvotes; Toronto

Jun 27th, 2016 10:32 am

djemzine wrote: ↑Not with my Corporate plan. Monthly fee is same regardless of contract or no contract/month to month/if bringing my own phone.

You should have mention that you are on a corporate plan. But to someone who does not have a corporate plan option the monthly fees usually start $60 to $80

Jun 27th, 2016 10:37 am

djemzine [OP]: Deal Expert; Jun 15, 2011; 43889 posts; 7527 upvotes

Jun 27th, 2016 10:37 am

cgtlky wrote: ↑You should have mention that you are on a corporate plan. But to someone who does not have a corporate plan option the monthly fees usually start $60 to $80

I know, I forgot lol. I edited my post.

I just wanted to know if the calculations I factored in to see which option would be cheaper.

Blanka

Jun 27th, 2016 10:42 am

WonderRocket: Jr. Member; Apr 21, 2016; 137 posts; 50 upvotes

Jun 27th, 2016 10:42 am

djemzine wrote: ↑Not with my Corporate plan. Monthly fee is same regardless of contract or no contract/month to month/if bringing my own phone.

edit: NVM

If you still have the same plan in both options, at the same price. Taking the subsidy will definitely be cheaper.

-Unless you are planning on travelling within the next three months. You can always unlock the phone anytime after 3 months with Rogers for $56.50
-So the downside is not being able to leave unless you pay cancellation fees. But that should just be paying off the device? Unless corp plan agreements are different.

Jun 27th, 2016 10:52 am

wilsonlam97: Deal Guru; Nov 19, 2010; 14709 posts; 2412 upvotes; Toronto

Jun 27th, 2016 10:52 am

Your calculation is correct. By taking the contract you effectively gain $13.33/month in hardware subsidies which means you're effectively paying ~$37/month (before taxes) for your plan.

Jun 27th, 2016 11:00 am

djemzine [OP]: Deal Expert; Jun 15, 2011; 43889 posts; 7527 upvotes

Jun 27th, 2016 11:00 am

wilsonlam97 wrote: ↑Your calculation is correct. By taking the contract you effectively gain $13.33/month in hardware subsidies which means you're effectively paying ~$37/month (before taxes) for your plan.

Thanks for confirming!

Blanka

Jun 27th, 2016 12:00 pm

will888: Deal Expert; Dec 12, 2009; 23999 posts; 13291 upvotes; Toronto

Jun 27th, 2016 12:00 pm

Tell me you didn't start this thread to incite jealousy? Definitely take the offer of cheap hardware. The freedom to not be tied down to a contract only matters if there were true options to defect to within the next 36 months. What's the likelihood of finding a carrier that will offer a 10 gig plan for less than $56.50? A lottery win in this Friday's lotto max draw is more likely, lol.

Jun 27th, 2016 12:29 pm

Piro21: Deal Expert; Nov 15, 2004; 20200 posts; 4029 upvotes; Toronto

Jun 27th, 2016 12:29 pm

The carrier doesn't offer a BYOD discount for using your own hardware? If that's the case it's better to accept their subsidized device as you're paying for it either way.

Jun 27th, 2016 12:43 pm

djemzine [OP]: Deal Expert; Jun 15, 2011; 43889 posts; 7527 upvotes

Jun 27th, 2016 12:43 pm

will888 wrote: ↑Tell me you didn't start this thread to incite jealousy? Definitely take the offer of cheap hardware. The freedom to not be tied down to a contract only matters if there were true options to defect to within the next 36 months. What's the likelihood of finding a carrier that will offer a 10 gig plan for less than $56.50? A lottery win in this Friday's lotto max draw is more likely, lol.

I swear - it was not meant for inciting jealousy lol. I was just curious, as I've seen various threads or posts about contract vs no contract pricing, benefits, etc.

Piro21 wrote: ↑The carrier doesn't offer a BYOD discount for using your own hardware? If that's the case it's better to accept their subsidized device as you're paying for it either way.

Nope, the price plan is the same for BYOD or signing up on a contract. Currently the three lines are on BYOD.

Blanka

Jun 27th, 2016 1:51 pm

wearysky: Deal Expert; Nov 28, 2013; 20612 posts; 10080 upvotes; Oakville

Jun 27th, 2016 1:51 pm

JIB9022 wrote: ↑Monthly fee cannot be same between contract option vs outright option;
contract option is always more expensive;
Monthly saving achieved by paying cheaper monthly plan offsets the outright cost in 2 years + getting unlocked phone etc

usually same plan (data, minutes) for BYOP and contract price differ by around 30-40 bucks at least; so ($30 savings per month x 24 = 720 savings total)
So leaving everything same, add 30 bucks to your contract calculation, and that should be about right

rogers minimum plan for contract is 80;

Actually... Rogers BYOD prices are the same as their smart tab prices these days.

will888 wrote: ↑Tell me you didn't start this thread to incite jealousy? Definitely take the offer of cheap hardware. The freedom to not be tied down to a contract only matters if there were true options to defect to within the next 36 months. What's the likelihood of finding a carrier that will offer a 10 gig plan for less than $56.50? A lottery win in this Friday's lotto max draw is more likely, lol.

Presuming the 10GB is full speed, yeah, this is smokin' hot. The next closest option is the Rogers Saskatchewan plan, $65 before tax for 10GB ($60 if you don't need Canada-wide calling) - and you obviously get stuck with a Sask number.

Jun 27th, 2016 4:07 pm

Shaner: Deal Expert; Jul 5, 2004; 26369 posts; 5355 upvotes

Jun 27th, 2016 4:07 pm

In your case it's a no brainer. Where people screw up is constantly signing a new term just to get a cheap phone. They keep getting worse plans for more money, often only $5 or $10 more, but that adds up over the years. I have a great plan for $50 that I've been on for a long time and will be until Rogers refuses to let me keep it. Those who are currently on crappy plans for $70+ per month have no one to blame but themselves. The savings of no contract vs contract aren't about the present, it's about the long term outlook. Most people had very good plans once upon a time, but they gave it up all to get a "cheap" iPhone or Samsung. In the end, they paid for the phone and are still paying for it, considering they'll never again get their cheap plans back.

A good plan is more important than a cheap phone. There's lots of options for phones out there, but once you lose a good plan, it's gone forever. People need to buy phones they can afford. If you have to "upgrade" to a worse, yet more expensive plan to get that phone you want, it clearly means you can't afford the phone. If you can't afford to pay for it outright, don't get it!

Jun 27th, 2016 4:30 pm

wearysky: Deal Expert; Nov 28, 2013; 20612 posts; 10080 upvotes; Oakville

Jun 27th, 2016 4:30 pm

Shaner wrote: ↑Most people had very good plans once upon a time, but they gave it up all to get a "cheap" iPhone or Samsung.

Part of the problem lies in the fact that those "very good plans" from once upon a time felt very much like overkill. "6GB a month for $30? But I've never used more than 750MB! And the vast majority of my phone usage is phone calls and text messages, and I can't get unlimited texts/minutes unless I bump up to a more expensive/less data plan!" - most people I know ended up spending less money monthly for their plans when they changed away from the awesome old data plans (because of no more overage charges, etc), even though *today* they would be saving more money (thanks to things like WhatsApp/Viber/whatever). And once they switched away from the 6GB data to 1GB data plans, if they wanted to bump up data plans after that they always got boned into paying for newer crappier plans. Very few people did a good job of predicting how much mobile data they'd actually want to be using 5 years down the road.

Add in to that the deceptive tactics used by the big 3 for years - where even if you tried to buy a phone outright from them, they still told you that you *had* to change your plan... And buying a phone outright was much more difficult than it is now... And it's no surprise we're in the position we are now.

Jun 27th, 2016 6:17 pm

will888: Deal Expert; Dec 12, 2009; 23999 posts; 13291 upvotes; Toronto

Jun 27th, 2016 6:17 pm

djemzine wrote: ↑I swear - it was not meant for inciting jealousy lol. I was just curious, as I've seen various threads or posts about contract vs no contract pricing, benefits, etc.

I am just kidding about inciting jealousy, although I am admittedly very jealous.

Jun 27th, 2016 6:41 pm

elwebmaster: Deal Addict; Aug 20, 2008; 2065 posts; 929 upvotes

Jun 27th, 2016 6:41 pm

That's not at all how you calculate the cost. You start by looking at your usage (text,voice,data) then finding the cheapest option that covers your needs (you can ask about it here too, people are very resourceful). Then you multiply the monthly cost by the number of months in your contract. You add the price of the phone (cheapest price, not the provider retail price, again you need to look for deals). Ideally you should be choosing the phone based on your needs also, but for simplicity let's assume only the one phone you mentioned meets your needs. That's the final number you compare to the total contract cost.

What's the point in having unlimited talk if you only talk 100 minutes a month and having 6GB data when your average usage is 1GB? That's why you always need to start from your usage pattern, not from the plan you are offered.

Jun 28th, 2016 7:56 pm

Bryan2B: Sr. Member; Sep 9, 2014; 604 posts; 563 upvotes; Vancouver

Jun 28th, 2016 7:56 pm

This is such a dump post. Of course if your plan costs the same whether you sign a contract (and take the subsidy) or not, then the on-contract option will be cheaper! Like seriously, how wouldn't it be? It's literally all the same except you pay less for your phone.

Jul 4th, 2016 2:50 pm

djemzine [OP]: Deal Expert; Jun 15, 2011; 43889 posts; 7527 upvotes

Jul 4th, 2016 2:50 pm

/Locked thread

Thanks to everyone for answering my questions.

Blanka

Locked

Top