Automotive

Replacing brake rotors/pads - OEM vs aftermarket?

  • Last Updated:
  • Feb 22nd, 2023 1:00 am
[OP]
Member
Jan 11, 2013
270 posts
25 upvotes
GTA

Replacing brake rotors/pads - OEM vs aftermarket?

I need to get my brake rotors/pads replaced on my 5-yr old Honda, and can either go to the dealership ($800) or a mechanic like iGarage for around half that. I've never had my brakes replaced before - is it better to go with the dealership to get Honda genuine parts, or are aftermarket's fine with negligible difference in quality? I'm just cautious about something as important as brakes, wondering if the extra cost is worth it for the genuine Honda parts. Thanks!
Last edited by curiousmoi on Feb 17th, 2023 6:15 pm, edited 1 time in total.
38 replies
Deal Addict
Oct 1, 2015
2840 posts
4014 upvotes
Barrie, ON
Aftermarket parts are fine. Just make sure they're from a reputable brand. Not some Maxbrakes garbage.
Deal Expert
User avatar
Jul 30, 2007
32191 posts
19486 upvotes
Toronto
You can ask Igarage to source the genuine brake parts and see how much the cost difference between dealer vs igarage and you can decide
Deal Fanatic
User avatar
Aug 24, 2016
9755 posts
11208 upvotes
The Prairies
You definitely don’t need Honda genuine brake components.
As mentioned, just don’t go with a cheap brand.
Tell the non dealer mechanic you want quality pads and rotors.
Deal Expert
Jan 15, 2006
20002 posts
20798 upvotes
Richmond Hill
I have nothing to add.

But, interesting title.
Deal Expert
User avatar
Feb 11, 2007
19929 posts
23505 upvotes
GTA
mxthor3 wrote: Aftermarket parts are fine. Just make sure they're from a reputable brand. Not some Maxbrakes garbage.
I used to think that as well but it's probably because people were getting the cheapest uncoated rotors. Uncoated brembos will also rust up incredibly quickly.
I took a chance an put their Geomet coated rotors on my dads car and so far over the past year they still look brand new (~120k km). For the price it's hard to go wrong, and certainly better than basic uncoated sets from brembo or wagner or centric.
Now on my car I use higher end coated centric or brembo rotors and stoptech or hawk pads.
Basically if you drive it in the winter, go for coated rotors. Now tesla has some amazing rotors. They don't rust at all, even the friction surface after rain. They must be some pricey rust resistant alloy, but not likely stainless steel.

OP, this is the set i would recommend for your car if it's a CRV, Geomet coated for $254 https://maxbrakes.com/product/kt275663/
If the women don't find you handsome, they should at least find you handy.
Newbie
Feb 28, 2013
80 posts
21 upvotes
Toronto
engineered wrote: I used to think that as well but it's probably because people were getting the cheapest uncoated rotors. Uncoated brembos will also rust up incredibly quickly.
I took a chance an put their Geomet coated rotors on my dads car and so far over the past year they still look brand new (~120k km). For the price it's hard to go wrong, and certainly better than basic uncoated sets from brembo or wagner or centric.
Now on my car I use higher end coated centric or brembo rotors and stoptech or hawk pads.
Basically if you drive it in the winter, go for coated rotors. Now tesla has some amazing rotors. They don't rust at all, even the friction surface after rain. They must be some pricey rust resistant alloy, but not likely stainless steel.

OP, this is the set i would recommend for your car if it's a CRV, Geomet coated for $254 https://maxbrakes.com/product/kt275663/
Totally agree with coated rotors and spend the extra dollars. Installed centric coated rotors on my 2014 Camry and has held up for two winters so far. Brakes still still smooth and responsive. Also helps I service my own brakes at least every year if you can do that.
Deal Addict
Oct 1, 2015
2840 posts
4014 upvotes
Barrie, ON
engineered wrote: I used to think that as well but it's probably because people were getting the cheapest uncoated rotors. Uncoated brembos will also rust up incredibly quickly.
I took a chance an put their Geomet coated rotors on my dads car and so far over the past year they still look brand new (~120k km). For the price it's hard to go wrong, and certainly better than basic uncoated sets from brembo or wagner or centric.
Now on my car I use higher end coated centric or brembo rotors and stoptech or hawk pads.
Basically if you drive it in the winter, go for coated rotors. Now tesla has some amazing rotors. They don't rust at all, even the friction surface after rain. They must be some pricey rust resistant alloy, but not likely stainless steel.

OP, this is the set i would recommend for your car if it's a CRV, Geomet coated for $254 https://maxbrakes.com/product/kt275663/
I wouldn't run Brembo, they're about as bad as anything out there. Coated rotors are definitely worth the extra $$$, especially in the climate we live in.
Member
Jan 23, 2014
459 posts
400 upvotes
Markham
If you can tell me what year and models. I can tell you more from there. Thanks
Deal Addict
Jul 22, 2019
2552 posts
3405 upvotes
Just don't go to a dealership. What is the going price for replacement of rear brakes/rotors anyways now a days for a typical Accord/civic?
Deal Addict
Oct 21, 2006
1068 posts
876 upvotes
for my 2017 RX350, I went with Raybesto's specialty rotors and akebono pads. This combo has been holding up very well for over 2yrs.
Deal Addict
User avatar
Aug 30, 2020
2411 posts
4553 upvotes
YEG/YYZ
Aftermarket is fine, as others said, just go for brand name coated ones and not the cheapest ones you can find.
Deal Expert
User avatar
Jun 12, 2007
19189 posts
6277 upvotes
London
Even the big aftermarket parts names like Raybestos have economy, mid and premium tiers

Go with the premium tier from any well known reputable manufacturer like Raybestos. Stay away from the economy tier
Deal Expert
User avatar
Mar 9, 2007
15179 posts
12083 upvotes
Think of the Childre…
Transit Auto on Amazon is alright.

WOULD SOMEBODY THINK OF THE CHILDREN!!!
Member
Apr 18, 2011
454 posts
208 upvotes
Toronto
After doing a fair amount of research, I have bought Raybestos Element 3 coated rotors and Akebono ProAct Ultra Premium Ceramic brake pads for my 2015 Toyota RAV4. I paid around $400 for the complete set.
Newbie
Oct 10, 2012
60 posts
23 upvotes
Woodbridge
I have been changing brakes myself for 30+ years on Hondas, Toyotas, VWs, and domestics.

Wherever you go to get the labour done, please go get genuine Honda parts first. They simply last longer.

What you save up front with aftermarket, you will end up giving back in the end.

I am also a firm believer in servicing your brakes every 2 years. That is, have a mechanic clean your calipers, lube your slider pins, and reapply lube to your shims.

You'll get a much longer service life out of them.
Deal Expert
User avatar
Feb 11, 2007
19929 posts
23505 upvotes
GTA
wormburner wrote: I have been changing brakes myself for 30+ years on Hondas, Toyotas, VWs, and domestics.

Wherever you go to get the labour done, please go get genuine Honda parts first. They simply last longer.

What you save up front with aftermarket, you will end up giving back in the end.

I am also a firm believer in servicing your brakes every 2 years. That is, have a mechanic clean your calipers, lube your slider pins, and reapply lube to your shims.

You'll get a much longer service life out of them.
Agree with servicing but not with OEM parts. Yes, they're better than cheap stuff, but quality aftermarket parts are often better.
If the women don't find you handsome, they should at least find you handy.
Member
Aug 25, 2015
226 posts
24 upvotes
Toronto
I have 2015 Honda CR-V, 160,000 km. I hear squeaking sound when i brake.
I'm going to do brake job myself first time. I watched some you tube videos, I think, i can do it.
I'm going to buy rotors and pads for front and rear from Honda dealer and install my self.
I'm going to buy coolant from Honda dealer and replace my self.
Some time, i get 5-20% discount from Honda dealer for parts.

I already changed engine oil, transmission fluid, differential fluid,o2 sensors, maf sensor, throttle cleaning, engine gasket,spark plugs, engine air filter, cabin filter my self.

Is this good anti-seize?
https://www.canadiantire.ca/en/pdp/perm ... ml?loc=plp

Is this good brake lubricant?
https://www.canadiantire.ca/en/pdp/perm ... ml?loc=plp


Thanks
Deal Expert
User avatar
Feb 11, 2007
19929 posts
23505 upvotes
GTA
Ahtusavis wrote: I have 2015 Honda CR-V, 160,000 km. I hear squeaking sound when i brake.
I'm going to do brake job myself first time. I watched some you tube videos, I think, i can do it.
I'm going to buy rotors and pads for front and rear from Honda dealer and install my self.
I'm going to buy coolant from Honda dealer and replace my self.
Some time, i get 5-20% discount from Honda dealer for parts.

I already changed engine oil, transmission fluid, differential fluid,o2 sensors, maf sensor, throttle cleaning, engine gasket,spark plugs, engine air filter, cabin filter my self.

Is this good anti-seize?
https://www.canadiantire.ca/en/pdp/perm ... ml?loc=plp

Is this good brake lubricant?
https://www.canadiantire.ca/en/pdp/perm ... ml?loc=plp

Thanks
Yes, those are both good. Just make sure you jack it up safely (with axle stands) and make sure you put it back together correctly. Following a good DIY is a good way to go. Make sure to clean up everything (especially caliper slider pins and apply new silicone lube).
Hopefully your rotors aren't stuck on the hubs. If they are, apply PB blaster or other rust release fluid to where the rotor meets the hub using the straw attachment. Use a mallet or hammer to loosen the rotor, being careful where you hit. A pry bar may also work, or a spreader, etc.
Be sure to put anti seize on the hub to prevent sticking.
If the women don't find you handsome, they should at least find you handy.
Deal Addict
Oct 1, 2015
2840 posts
4014 upvotes
Barrie, ON
5lb sledge is what you want if rotors are stuck. It's being replaced, no need to be gentle with it. Should come off with one good wack. No PB Blaster required.

Top

Thread Information

There is currently 1 user viewing this thread. (0 members and 1 guest)