• Last Updated:
  • Oct 7th, 2020 8:19 pm
Tags:
[OP]
Deal Addict
Dec 20, 2015
3714 posts
1980 upvotes
Toronto, ON

Used Tesla

Hey guys, so I'm considering to buy a used Tesla maybe a Model 3 or Model Y. Both in AWD, but was wondering is it worth saving 5 - 10 K in MSRP price for a used Tesla, or should I just buy directly from Tesla themselves?

I've seen:

2018 Tesla Model 3, with 28K KM for $65K
2020 Tesla Model Y, with 1150KM for $71K

What is your take on this? And why Tesla? Trying to save money on Gas. But does it really drop in KM range in winter time? How much $$ am I really saving?

Any Tesla owners can chime in on Electricity per month they are paying to charge their cars? Thanks in advance!!!
If you like the post or the comment, then don't forget to SMASH that LIKE BUTTON!
50 replies
Deal Addict
User avatar
Jan 15, 2013
1675 posts
1318 upvotes
Ottawa
You lost me at "Trying to save money on Gas". If that's the case buy anything else "new" for a lot less and you're saving money immediately.
Deal Addict
Jan 20, 2005
3712 posts
331 upvotes
Thornhill
I would get a brand new model 3 over model y. Model y has some build quality issues since its the first year run. My parents own a model 3 and its been flawless. Remember thoe this is a computer on wheels .
Deal Expert
Jun 30, 2006
19458 posts
7645 upvotes
Toronto
If are you concerned about saving 5-10K, I wouldn't get a Tesla.
Jr. Member
Dec 14, 2012
108 posts
55 upvotes
Ottawa
What the first guy said.

Buy a used Camry and drive it to the ground. The $50k difference buys you a lot of gas.
Deal Addict
Jul 21, 2009
1305 posts
771 upvotes
Toronto
Buy a Tesla because you like Tesla, not because you think its going to save you any money.

BTW you can buy a brand new Model 3 for 48k + tax in Ontario after the rebate.
Deal Addict
User avatar
Aug 10, 2015
1903 posts
733 upvotes
Elgin, ON
I've recently been evaluating buying a used Model 3. Where I'm sitting right now, new is too much money, and used does not yield sufficient savings to make it a slam dunk. Your budget may differ.

I agree with the poster above, who said don't buy a Tesla to save money. In addition to high purchase price, depreciation and insurance costs are significant, and can't be overlooked. Cost of driving / owning may not be as low as you think.

Currently, my wife and I have moved to considering the Kona Electric. We are not likely to buy in 2020 though, as we will be settling into a new house later this month.
Deal Fanatic
User avatar
May 25, 2009
8841 posts
2076 upvotes
rkjredflag wrote: I've recently been evaluating buying a used Model 3. Where I'm sitting right now, new is too much money, and used does not yield sufficient savings to make it a slam dunk. Your budget may differ.

I agree with the poster above, who said don't buy a Tesla to save money. In addition to high purchase price, depreciation and insurance costs are significant, and can't be overlooked. Cost of driving / owning may not be as low as you think.

Currently, my wife and I have moved to considering the Kona Electric. We are not likely to buy in 2020 though, as we will be settling into a new house later this month.
To be fair, Model 3 depreciation is stupid low right now. That can and will almost certainly change though but so far Teslas comparatively still depreciates a lot less than other cars.

In terms of insurance, that's going to depend on a thousand factors and can vary widely. But FWIW, we're paying ~$2,160 a year for the insurance on our 2020 M3 SR+. Our other car is a 2013 Elantra GT and the insurance on that is costing us ~$1,850 a year or only about $25 less a month.

Not siding with the Tesla option here either way, just wanted to point some of those numbers out.
"God's in His heaven. All's right with the world." - Robert Browning (1812-1889)
Deal Addict
User avatar
Aug 10, 2015
1903 posts
733 upvotes
Elgin, ON
Winkle wrote: To be fair, Model 3 depreciation is stupid low right now. That can and will almost certainly change though but so far Teslas comparatively still depreciates a lot less than other cars.

In terms of insurance, that's going to depend on a thousand factors and can vary widely. But FWIW, we're paying ~$2,160 a year for the insurance on our 2020 M3 SR+. Our other car is a 2013 Elantra GT and the insurance on that is costing us ~$1,850 a year or only about $25 less a month.

Not siding with the Tesla option here either way, just wanted to point some of those numbers out.
Thanks for chiming in with some rates.

I'll admit I had not dug into it deep, but I was playing around with the CAA cost of driving calculator the other day, and found they were rating the cost of driving the Model 3 as way higher than I expected. Insurance and depreciation were significantly higher than the 8 year old car my wife is currently driving. I understand those are only rough estimates though.

OP gives insufficient information for us to compare costs of driving a 3 or a Y to their current transportation solution.
Deal Addict
User avatar
Oct 16, 2007
1451 posts
681 upvotes
2 years old to save 5K? Not a chance. The extra warranty would be well worth it.
- Insert Something here so you will be able to recognize me.
Deal Addict
Jul 21, 2009
1305 posts
771 upvotes
Toronto
rkjredflag wrote: Thanks for chiming in with some rates.

I'll admit I had not dug into it deep, but I was playing around with the CAA cost of driving calculator the other day, and found they were rating the cost of driving the Model 3 as way higher than I expected. Insurance and depreciation were significantly higher than the 8 year old car my wife is currently driving. I understand those are only rough estimates though.
Depreciation is in a weird state because the rebate incentives changed and Model 3 supply is still short. Buyers who bought in 2018 were able to take advantage of a 14k rebate.

Here is a guy who broke down his cost of ownership over 2 years https://www.reddit.com/r/PersonalFinanc ... _my_tesla/

TL;DR he spent 80k over 28 months and will be lucky to get 50k back if he sold.
Deal Fanatic
User avatar
May 25, 2009
8841 posts
2076 upvotes
rkjredflag wrote: Thanks for chiming in with some rates.

I'll admit I had not dug into it deep, but I was playing around with the CAA cost of driving calculator the other day, and found they were rating the cost of driving the Model 3 as way higher than I expected. Insurance and depreciation were significantly higher than the 8 year old car my wife is currently driving. I understand those are only rough estimates though.

OP gives insufficient information for us to compare costs of driving a 3 or a Y to their current transportation solution.
Yeah, it's kinda hard to look at articles and online calculator, the actual numbers are going to be highly dependent on many variables and factors on a case by case basis.
"God's in His heaven. All's right with the world." - Robert Browning (1812-1889)
Deal Fanatic
Sep 1, 2004
7489 posts
6414 upvotes
Expect your energy bill to be 1/5 of gas. ie. If you spend $3K/year in gas, you will spend $600 in electricity. More if you go to Superchargers.

As I have caution many on BEVs, don't use $ as the primary reason. It will turn you off EVs fairly quickly.

EV, especially Tesla, what you are paying for:
- Not go to gas pump to refuel
- emission 0 or low emission depends on your electricity source
- Silent drive, great acceleration
- One of the better driver assist program available.
- the image of not burning fuel

If your starting point is money, remember that you can buy and operate a new RAV4 for 8 years for the initial purchase price of a base Model Y. The argument may be better against a fully loaded X3.
Deal Addict
User avatar
Sep 23, 2009
3582 posts
1105 upvotes
Oshawa, ON
rkjredflag wrote: Thanks for chiming in with some rates.

I'll admit I had not dug into it deep, but I was playing around with the CAA cost of driving calculator the other day, and found they were rating the cost of driving the Model 3 as way higher than I expected. Insurance and depreciation were significantly higher than the 8 year old car my wife is currently driving. I understand those are only rough estimates though.

OP gives insufficient information for us to compare costs of driving a 3 or a Y to their current transportation solution.
As a Tesla Model 3 owner, I wanted to chime in on a few things. I saved a significant amount of money on the first year of ownership alone.

  • My insurance dropped by 30% due to the safety features of the vehicle and Tesla's very high safety ratings
  • From paying $200-$250 a month on gas to $30-$50 a month on electricity (sometimes, I don't pay any at all due to some of the free charging stations out there).
  • With the use of regenerative braking, I never have to use my brakes. Therefore, I save my brake pads from wearing down and at the same time, it recharges a bit of my battery. That's killing two birds with one stone. Depending on your driving style, the brakes can actually last 8 years+. My mobile tech with a 2012 Model S still has his OEM brake pads from 8 years ago.
  • $200+ saved from not needing to do oil changes and the lack of maintenance of electric vehicles

In addition, most car manufacturers charge a couple hundred dollars for software updates for their GPS maps. The Hyundai Kona for example, will charge for this AND an annual fee ($150?) for the Bluelink service if you want it. In contrast, Tesla provides updates for FREE for life and in contrast to Bluelink, Tesla's app is also free. While most car manufacturers provide software updates for the maps / infotainment system, Tesla's updates physically improve how the vehicle performs (eg: more HP, better battery conservation, camera improvements, ease of use improvements etc). The software updates alone is why the resale value is so high on Teslas, other car manufacturers require them to physically change something and will upsell it's the latest and greatest on next year's model. Tesla doesn't have model years.
Last edited by EnyCe on Oct 7th, 2020 1:35 pm, edited 3 times in total.
Deal Addict
User avatar
Aug 10, 2015
1903 posts
733 upvotes
Elgin, ON
Xtrema wrote: Expect your energy bill to be 1/5 of gas. ie. If you spend $3K/year in gas, you will spend $600 in electricity. More if you go to Superchargers.

As I have caution many on BEVs, don't use $ as the primary reason. It will turn you off EVs fairly quickly.

EV, especially Tesla, what you are paying for:
- Not go to gas pump to refuel
- emission 0 or low emission depends on your electricity source
- Silent drive, great acceleration
- One of the better driver assist program available.
- the image of not burning fuel

If your starting point is money, remember that you can buy and operate a new RAV4 for 8 years for the initial purchase price of a base Model Y. The argument may be better against a fully loaded X3.
Nice little summary.

I completely agree that if you only value dollars and cents, a Tesla, or other BEV is not the best choice.

For some reason, my wife really hates filling up on gas, so sees a lot of value in at home charging. Her current vehicle has a small gas tank, and fairly low range, so she has to fill up at least twice a week.
Deal Expert
Jan 15, 2006
17045 posts
15658 upvotes
Richmond Hill
For those whose insurance went down with the Model 3, mine was the opposite. We had a 2014 Volt and was paying $1400/yr and now it's just under $2000/yr with the Model 3. Maybe being the performance model has something do with it??? It is the most expensive vehicle to insure in my household...
Deal Expert
Jan 15, 2006
17045 posts
15658 upvotes
Richmond Hill
rkjredflag wrote: Nice little summary.

I completely agree that if you only value dollars and cents, a Tesla, or other BEV is not the best choice.

For some reason, my wife really hates filling up on gas, so sees a lot of value in at home charging. Her current vehicle has a small gas tank, and fairly low range, so she has to fill up at least twice a week.
Not having to fill up gas is a life changer. My wife loves never needing to fill up and has been almost fuel free since 2014 (she had a Volt that needed to be filled up in winter). Also don't forget no oil changes so that's another hassle off the list as well. Sounds minor, but it's less things to do.
Deal Fanatic
User avatar
May 25, 2009
8841 posts
2076 upvotes
EP32k2 wrote: For those whose insurance went down with the Model 3, mine was the opposite. We had a 2014 Volt and was paying $1400/yr and now it's just under $2000/yr with the Model 3. Maybe being the performance model has something do with it??? It is the most expensive vehicle to insure in my household...
What was the price of your 2014 Volt though? Quick google shows that 2014 Volt started at $36.9K CAD in Canada... Model 3 Performance is just under $75K... that's double the price so yeah, there's no way insurance is gonna go down if you go to a vehicle at twice the price.
"God's in His heaven. All's right with the world." - Robert Browning (1812-1889)
Deal Fanatic
Sep 1, 2004
7489 posts
6414 upvotes
rkjredflag wrote: Nice little summary.

I completely agree that if you only value dollars and cents, a Tesla, or other BEV is not the best choice.

For some reason, my wife really hates filling up on gas, so sees a lot of value in at home charging. Her current vehicle has a small gas tank, and fairly low range, so she has to fill up at least twice a week.
Right now I WFH and uses at least 30% less fuel than pre-COVID. So the saving to gas station and gas is even harder to overcome by paying the EV premium. On the flip side, my BIL get pay per mileage to use his own car, so other than a few range anxiety issue for a few locations, he's making bank with Model 3.

Top