Shopping Discussion

Wayfair is NOT worth the hype

  • Last Updated:
  • Sep 13th, 2022 1:01 pm

Poll: Has anyone else had a negative experience with Wayfair?

  • Total votes: 36. You have voted on this poll.
Yes
 
12
33%
No
 
24
67%
[OP]
Newbie
Feb 28, 2022
12 posts
21 upvotes

Wayfair is NOT worth the hype

The entire experience from beginning to end was unsatisfactory.

To begin, has anyone tried filtering their search so that they don’t have to look through a zillion items to find what they are looking for? When I typed my search criteria in the fields provided, I didn’t actually receive anything that met that criteria. I tried a number of times to filter in various ways, but none of the filtered “matches” actually matched the criteria I typed in. I ended up literally spending hours going through all the items – in this case shelves – just to find an item that came close to what I was looking for. When I eventually found an item that came closest, it was out-of-stock. When I inserted my email address so that Wayfair would notify me when the item would be back in stock, I did not get notified. I had to keep checking their website as to when the item would be re-stocked and that date kept getting pushed forward. In case you’re wondering, I set up the alert to be notified on December 9th, 2021 and I still have not been notified. When I just checked their website, the re-stock date has, yet again, been pushed forward.

Since I got tired of waiting and wanted to purchase a shelving unit before the beginning of the New Year, I decided to look for a different shelving unit. So, once again, I spent hours going through shelves on their website and eventually stumbled upon one that would suffice. I ended up purchasing two shelving units on December 30th, 2021. I received each shelving unit a little more than a week later on two different days.

I ended up using one shelving unit, but not the other so I decided to request a return. When I looked up their return policy, I found out that I had passed the 30-day return window, but thought that I could possibly get a store credit. When I called Wayfair, the customer service representative (CSR) simply reiterated the return policy, which I thought was redundant. Admittedly, I was twenty days passed the 30-day return window, but I pleadingly let her know that the item was unopened and still in its original shipping container – I hadn’t even unsealed the item or removed any stickers. I said I understood that I could not get a refund, but could I, at least, get a store credit? She said that if I was just a couple of days passed the return period, she could make an exception, but could not otherwise.

I read online from a reliable source that Wayfair would give a store credit for an unopened item if it was returned within 90 days of the delivery date. However, this turned out to be false since I was just twenty days passed the 30-day return window, and did not get a store credit.

I was actually annoyed at their lack of consideration because Wayfair’s prices are relatively high as if they have brick-and-mortar stores scattered all across North America, which they don’t. I don’t understand why their prices are so high since everything is basically shipped from a warehouse or from wherever it was made. I naively thought they’d be more accommodating to a first-time customer to encourage repeat business, but that clearly wasn’t the case.

In retrospect, I should’ve looked at the return policy before purchasing. If I did, I wouldn’t have purchased from them in the first place. A measly 30-day return policy for items that have not been opened is just absurd in my opinion. The CSR didn’t even seem compassionate. I believe that the primary purpose of any CSR is to work with the customer so that there is some level of satisfaction at the end of the conversation. However, this CSR seemed like she did not want to work with me.

Going back to the return policy, other companies have longer return policies even if the item is opened. I, on the other hand, did not even open the item and it had been less than two months since the item was delivered to me, and I still wasn’t allowed to return it. If the item was opened, I would understand the push-back. However, I literally had not opened the item or even touched the item since it was delivered. That means, the item is still in sellable condition since it had not been removed from its packaging. All Wayfair literally has to do is slap a new shipping label on top of my shipping label and send it to its new buyer. And, as for the cost of shipping it back, I believe that was covered when I initially bought the item. As I already mentioned, the prices are just unbelievably high so I have to justify that return shipping is included in the purchase price.

I was on the fence when I finished my initial transaction with Wayfair, and even let them know that when I filled out the survey I received after my purchase. Since seeing their return policy and speaking to their CSR, I definitely would not recommend Wayfair at all. Just to let you know, once I realized I was not going to be able to return the product, I filled out their feedback form on their website explaining my case. The response I got back was, once again, a reiteration of their return policy, a suggestion that I sell the item online and a skimpy ten percent discount on my next purchase (which had an expiry date by the way). I just let them know that they could keep their paltry discount since I wouldn’t be shopping with them anymore.

You may be wondering why I purchased from Wayfair in the first place since I mentioned earlier that their prices are high. Well, the pandemic kept me from venturing outside because I live in a high-risk zone, where the virus is rampant. In order to limit my exposure, I explored online furniture sites such as Wayfair, which I thought was a reputable site. You can rest assured, though, that Wayfair is not going to see another dollar from me since this was my first and last time buying from them.

Good riddance, Wayfair.
13 replies
Deal Expert
User avatar
Jan 9, 2011
16428 posts
22575 upvotes
Vancouver
I'm boycotting this poll.
You bought something and tried to return it for no other reason than "I changed my mind", and outside of the merchant's 30-day return window. And you're making a big fuss because they didn't make an exception to the return policy that you evidently didn't read.
Ya sorry not much sympathy here.
Deal Expert
User avatar
Oct 5, 2008
17145 posts
12628 upvotes
Toronto
TLDR
Kiraly wrote: I'm boycotting this poll.
You bought something and tried to return it for no other reason than "I changed my mind", and outside of the merchant's 30-day return window. And you're making a big fuss because they didn't make an exception to the return policy that you evidently didn't read.
Ya sorry not much sympathy here.
Thanks for the Coles Notes version.
Deal Expert
Aug 22, 2006
29848 posts
15364 upvotes
CaveatEmptor2022 wrote: She said that if I was just a couple of days passed the return period, she could make an exception, but could not otherwise.
This sounds like good customer service to me...
Do you not have anything else to do rather than argue with strangers on the internet
Nope. That's why I'm on the internet arguing with strangers. If I had anything better to do I'd probably be doing it.
Deal Fanatic
Jan 21, 2008
7762 posts
4078 upvotes
Customer service was excellent. I bought an item that ended up looking very different from the picture and description. I am a fair & reasonable person, if it was off slightly I wouldn't even complain or ask for compensation, I would just keep it. Wayfair offered to reduce the price but I said no, I would rather return it & get a full refund. They ended up giving me a full refund & allowed me to keep it. Yes, it sucked that the item was not as described, but the customer service experience meant that I would still consider them in the future.
Deal Expert
User avatar
Oct 5, 2008
17145 posts
12628 upvotes
Toronto
I hade a similar situation. My wife ordered something that turned out to be not as described, they refunded the $ and they told us to keep the item
Newbie
Feb 23, 2021
31 posts
51 upvotes
CaveatEmptor2022 wrote:
I ended up literally spending hours going through all the items – in this case shelves – just to find an item that came close to what I was looking for.

So, once again, I spent hours going through shelves on their website and eventually stumbled upon one that would suffice.

Admittedly, I was twenty days passed the 30-day return window.

I was actually annoyed at their lack of consideration because Wayfair’s prices are relatively high as if they have brick-and-mortar stores scattered all across North America, which they don’t. I don’t understand why their prices are so high

In retrospect, I should’ve looked at the return policy before purchasing.
As I already mentioned, the prices are just unbelievably high so I have to justify that return shipping is included in the purchase price.

Good riddance, Wayfair.
LOL you are the kind of costumer they don't want back. You hate their site, literally spending "several hours" multiple times to find a shelf. You find their pricing "unbelievably high". You admit you never bothered to look at their return window, and are chewing out min. wage staff because you are way the hell passed it. I mean 50 days to realize you don't want a shelf, really?

Check your entitlement, as someone on their end just said "Good riddance, CaveatEmptor2022'.
Deal Addict
Jan 12, 2017
3132 posts
3932 upvotes
Langley
When did Wayfair ever have "hype"?
Newbie
Jul 1, 2019
26 posts
14 upvotes
On the legitimate complaint: looking for something through the wayfair website is actually a headache.

One tip is to use google shopping and enter "(store name) (product name)"
Deal Fanatic
Jun 13, 2010
6956 posts
8980 upvotes
GTA
The return policy applies to all items not just opened items. A lot of companies have a 30 day return policy which is reasonable, it's plenty of time to decide if you want to keep what you purchased. You would get the same response from almost all retailers when trying to do a return 3 weeks after the return period.
Deal Expert
Feb 7, 2017
23965 posts
23063 upvotes
Eastern Ontario
Oh goodie …
Another person who believes the customer is always right
Despite how ridiculous the customer behaves
:facepalm:
Sr. Member
Oct 15, 2013
890 posts
1339 upvotes
I hope the CSR that had to deal with this has a relaxing weekend at least.
Deal Addict
User avatar
Dec 13, 2016
4350 posts
3888 upvotes
If you want to scam sellers then you should buy from Amazon
Deal Fanatic
User avatar
Jul 29, 2005
9140 posts
3025 upvotes
Mississauga
I ordered from Wayfair for the first time. Now their US office have been spamming me with multiple calls to signup for a business account. Has anyone else experienced this?
My food blog - Reggie The Food Critic.

Top