Before the Hi-Fi hate squad comes in...
I have often heard the comparison between watching SD and 4k content used. But to me I think the difference is more nuanced and less perceptible. It's more like the difference between Tier 0 and tier 3 4K bluray encoding, see below if you don't know what I'm referring to.bhrm wrote: ↑ Before the Hi-Fi hate squad comes in...
Yes it's $800 and there's a million other things you can buy for $800 and have something better.
It's great for someone who wants the purest audio experience, and need more power to push their $300-500 headphones. It's great for someone who doesn't work from home (basically no one right now) and want to bring it to the office, coffee shop, on flights/trains.
WHY not a smartphone?? Yes smartphones are pretty decent to pretty awesome for audio, I have a little DAC that was $35 and can do hi-res audio etc etc but....it's not a dedicated device, sometimes other audio interrupts, notifications, or by accident i close the player etc etc.
Also it looks sweet in-person! Solid build and all.
Would I buy one? Not an A&K, but there's alternatives like Fiio. I'm not a big fan of wearing headphones for long periods of time unless i'm commuting on the train.
TL;DR - If you want to hear every little tiny detail, breath, click or clack and have money to burn.
Also depends on your ears, highly subjective. If you grew up with music, play instruments, took classes, perfect pitch etc then you'll be more likely to appreciate the quality difference. If listening to music on a high end system gives you 'the chills' then yes.majorwang wrote: ↑ I have often heard the comparison between watching SD and 4k content used. But to me I think the difference is more nuanced and less perceptible. It's more like the difference between Tier 0 and tier 3 4K bluray encoding, see below if you don't know what I'm referring to.
https://www.avsforum.com/forum/150-blu- ... cs/2895785
In any case the difference perceived between a smartphone streaming at 1411kbps uncompressed flac (available on Tidal) and that device seems exceedingly small, and made worse by that $800 price tag and yet another device to occupy in the pocket.
My smartphone has a petty high end hi-fi Quad DAC and battery life and form factor are great. I guess most consumers simply don't care about this stuff (it wasn't the top selling feature for me either but I do appreciate it). But any audiophiles out there trying to cut down on their rig should be aware the LG G7 has great audio output and is still a very well-performing smartphone in 2020. The G8 has the DAC too.bhrm wrote: ↑ Before the Hi-Fi hate squad comes in...
Yes it's $800 and there's a million other things you can buy for $800 and have something better.
It's great for someone who wants the purest audio experience, and need more power to push their $300-500 headphones. It's great for someone who doesn't work from home (basically no one right now) and want to bring it to the office, coffee shop, on flights/trains.
WHY not a smartphone?? Yes smartphones are pretty decent to pretty awesome for audio, I have a little DAC that was $35 and can do hi-res audio etc etc but....it's not a dedicated device, sometimes other audio interrupts, notifications, or by accident i close the player etc etc.
Also it looks sweet in-person! Solid build and all.
Would I buy one? Not an A&K, but there's alternatives like Fiio. I'm not a big fan of wearing headphones for long periods of time unless i'm commuting on the train.
TL;DR - If you want to hear every little tiny detail, breath, click or clack and have money to burn.
Would you say the perceptible difference is further degraded by listening environment? Like trying to pick out the timbre of a guitar string in a loud starbucks or airplane cabin versus quiet bedroom?bhrm wrote: ↑ Also depends on your ears, highly subjective. If you grew up with music, play instruments, took classes, perfect pitch etc then you'll be more likely to appreciate the quality difference. If listening to music on a high end system gives you 'the chills' then yes.
Don't forget your ears degrade over time, mostly at the 10-20hz range. As you age you'll lose ability to hear up there, so YOLO! Buy now as you won't appreciate later.
I heard great things for audio, but as a phone not so much and LG phones are....flakey.polish_jr333 wrote: ↑ My smartphone has a petty high end hi-fi Quad DAC and battery life and form factor are great. I guess most consumers simply don't care about this stuff (it wasn't the top selling feature for me either but I do appreciate it). But any audiophiles out there trying to cut down on their rig should be aware the LG G7 has great audio output and is still a very well-performing smartphone in 2020. The G8 has the DAC too.
Depends on your headphones and how isolating they are. If Loud Howard is sitting next to you on a plane or coffee shop, probably not great.
I had the V20 when the quad dac first came out. Currently have a G7 and a Q1Mk2.polish_jr333 wrote: ↑ My smartphone has a petty high end hi-fi Quad DAC and battery life and form factor are great. I guess most consumers simply don't care about this stuff (it wasn't the top selling feature for me either but I do appreciate it). But any audiophiles out there trying to cut down on their rig should be aware the LG G7 has great audio output and is still a very well-performing smartphone in 2020. The G8 has the DAC too.
you've got a G7 with a decent DAC biult-in but still added a Fiio? Dang... I find the G7 drives powerfully.
I use them separately. The Q1Mk2 is used with an older phone of mine.polish_jr333 wrote: ↑ you've got a G7 with a decent DAC biult-in but still added a Fiio? Dang... I find the G7 drives powerfully.
I was looking at the Fiio M11 (and the M11 Pro)...they are rather tempting.jdewit wrote: ↑ Many people are content with the cameras on their cell phones - and many people have more than $800 invested in camera equipment. To each his own. If the audio on your phone works for you, great. I prefer a dedicated device myself, though not at this price point. There are decent, cheaper, alternatives and my ears aren't what they used to be.
Edit: 128GB internal and max 256GB microSD would be a deal breaker for me anyways. The newer Fiios support up to 2TB. FLAC & HDaudio files will fill a lot of space quickly.
To me, I think it's definitely more of a subjectively driven desire to have a great sounding audio player. Something that's more focused on the experience of being an audio player instead of, say, a phone. With the more restricted / limited capabilities, it means I'll just be looking at it for music playback, and as a USB DAC. I don't have to think about processor speed, app updates, security updates. Plus, I think it's a decent 'object' to 'look at'. Kinda like furniture, if you will; task specific, functional...but nice to look at as well.
There is currently 1 user viewing this thread. (0 members and 1 guest)
