YMMV deals should be banned

ben35 wrote: ↑ Pretty frustrating to read the endless cell phone YMMV deals threads only to never be able to get the 'deal'.

This also applies to other YMMV posts. What about just banning the practice of posting anything that is not widely available, or maybe maiking a sub subforum for YMMV deals?

That means you'd only end up with deals that are online and/or available from nationwide retailers, though.

Personally I think we should define YMMV better. Like if a deal is in-store, the fact that you may go to the store and it's sold out, in my opinion that's not YMMV, that's just the nature of stores. The fact that your Walmart may not have the item doesn't make the Canada-wide Walmart deal YMMV or expired. I think YMMV speaks more to things that aren't cut and dried - like if you have to negotiate for a deal, or badger customer service to give you a discount code, or retentions, or if it's an obvious price error, or if it's a personalized code from a newsletter or something and you don't know if everyone got it, or things like that. Right now, YMMV is basically used everywhere as a shield against people downvoting because their store didn't have something or that store doesn't exist in their area or things that really just make me kind of sad about the community. YMMV should really just be for the deals that are a little bit sketchy when you think about them long enough.

ben35 wrote: ↑ Pretty frustrating to read the endless cell phone YMMV deals threads only to never be able to get the 'deal'.

This also applies to other YMMV posts. What about just banning the practice of posting anything that is not widely available, or maybe maiking a sub subforum for YMMV deals?

People will just remove YMMV" from title and continue to post them:))

YMMV deals are often available to a lot of people, just not everyone. YMMV deals are some of the best deals you can get. While not available to everyone, eventually one will be available to you, and you'll be thankful someone alerted you to it.

It is the same for us that live in non-GTA areas, such as BC. More than half the deals are not available to us

kramer1 wrote: ↑ It is the same for us that live in non-GTA areas, such as BC. More than half the deals are not available to us

Better than Quebec:)))

Sometimes, a deal looks like it's for everyone, but is only YMMV, while other times, it's just not easy to tell if it's YMMV, especially if you're a newbie.

At worst, a deal I'm not eligible for is only going to waste a minute out of my day. That's a good tradeoff for the potential benefit or even just the knowledge of a deal (which I can tell others who aren't on RFD about).

i don't see much point in 'banning" - doing so would turn away people with good intentions from contributing to the site.

after all a lot of users do not work for rfd - they are just sharing whatever they can around themselves.

getting the proper description of the deal would be the key, which relies heavily on individual posters and mods..

BTW i don't have much luck in ymmv deals myself so i generally avoid them.

Here's a pretty good example of what I said in my previous post:

I joined Amazon Prime on a 6 month student trial then at the student rate of $39/year. I've been out of school for 5+ years and have not had a student email account in probably 4 years. Clearly a YMMV post imo as it's only supposed to be for students. My reply in the thread prompted someone to PM me how I snagged the promo. Also shared the deal with a friend whose returned to school.

Someone posted about a Bell internet deal few days ago. Total YMMV. I wasn't eligible, but when going my account I did learn I can upgrade my plan for an extra $10 - calling in tomorrow to inquire about it actually. I've had a lot on my mind recently and I wouldn't have thought to check my account if they hadn't posted about it. It's unfortunate OP's deal didn't work out for me, but thanks to their post, I might snag another deal, which is sure as hell better than nothing.

I have everything to gain from YMMV posts and nothing to lose except a few minutes here and there. And If I don't have a few minutes to spare here and there then I have bigger problems then a YMMV post

It's a pretty easy thing to ignore and Tom has mentioned they're working on new filtering for this sort of thing in the future. YMMV deals and price errors have been responsible for some of my best finds on here so I disagree they should be banned. I have noticed that some YMMV deals hang around in Hot Deals too long though.

YMMV deals is what built RFD in the early days.

The problem here is that posters are not putting enough information (location) in the thread title, and not the deal itself. For cell plans, posters should be specifically labelling what province they're in.